{
  "schemaVersion": "gships-review-packet-1",
  "packetId": "public-synthesis:alternatives",
  "stableId": "alternatives",
  "family": "public-synthesis",
  "slug": "alternatives",
  "title": "Alternatives, noncompensatory vetoes, and decision outcomes",
  "status": "prepared-human-review-not-started",
  "release": {
    "releaseId": "public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14",
    "sourceCommit": "3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0",
    "corpusGeneratedAt": "2026-07-25",
    "frozenAt": "2026-07-26T22:50:50.000Z",
    "canonicalOrigin": "https://gships.dammonburden.com"
  },
  "paths": {
    "human": "/review/public-synthesis/alternatives",
    "family": "/review/public-synthesis",
    "packet": "/review-packets/public-synthesis/alternatives.aeaa7aaecf647c37.json",
    "decisionTemplate": "/review-packets/public-synthesis/alternatives.aeaa7aaecf647c37.decision-template.json",
    "worksheet": "/review-packets/public-synthesis/alternatives.aeaa7aaecf647c37.worksheet.md",
    "byFingerprint": "/review-packets/by-fingerprint/aeaa7aaecf647c371fd044dff812b89adbb9c00d9a38d2b5f38aeabfe6871c22.json"
  },
  "boundary": "Prepared review packet; human review has not started. This packet is not a completed review, endorsement, reviewer appointment, partnership, or authorization to act.",
  "governingPolicies": [
    {
      "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001",
      "version": "0.1.0",
      "path": "/editorial-policy",
      "recordType": "governing-policy",
      "fingerprint": "1f6a1f823e8bfe891b6a707c5dce2ee2337c0bb7d915b48d6060ca82b8da1b47",
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001",
        "version": "0.1.0",
        "status": "foundation-policy-controls-not-yet-staffed",
        "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25",
        "title": "Editorial governance and independent review",
        "publisher": "GShips Project",
        "maintainer": "Dammon Burden",
        "publisherInterest": "The maintainer intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work. No entity, outside funding, customer, sponsor, or indexed-organization relationship currently exists.",
        "currentBoundary": "No independent domain reviewer or review council is currently appointed. Foundation records and outlines may not be represented as independently reviewed.",
        "reviewerSelection": [
          "Publish the reviewer’s name, relevant credentials or lived expertise, review scope, compensation status, and declared conflicts with consent.",
          "Select for the actual claim domain rather than general prestige; include affected-community and disability-led expertise where rights or access are involved.",
          "Do not treat an employee, investor, customer, sponsor, source author, or directly supervised collaborator as independent for the affected claim."
        ],
        "reviewProcess": [
          "Provide the exact claim, sources, locators, assumptions, counterevidence, transfer limits, and proposed evidence dimensions.",
          "Record approve, revise, contest, or reject at claim level; silence and event attendance never count as review.",
          "Publish material minority findings and the editor’s reasoned response.",
          "High-consequence medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use claims require two qualified independent reviewers with complementary scopes.",
          "A reviewer may recuse at any time; unresolved conflicts or missing expertise block the reviewed label."
        ],
        "appealAndCorrection": [
          "A correction receives a reference identifier and triage record; safety-critical allegations receive priority.",
          "A material editorial decision may be appealed to a reviewer not involved in the original decision once such a panel exists.",
          "Substantive reversals, unresolved disputes, and removed conclusions receive a dated public record that protects reporter privacy.",
          "No sponsor, customer, founder, or reviewer may purchase, suppress, or unilaterally assign an evidence grade."
        ],
        "publicationGate": "Public 1.0 requires named review coverage across every Academy track, documented high-consequence two-person review, a material-corrections log, reviewer conflict records, and an operating appeal path.",
        "correctionPath": "/corrections"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "policy-dual-use-001",
      "version": "0.1.0",
      "path": "/dual-use",
      "recordType": "governing-policy",
      "fingerprint": "81637e2849f9c0866d23f7174eb9a2ce522b86313167ebf5022fca122d6e506c",
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "policy-dual-use-001",
        "version": "0.1.0",
        "status": "planned-controls-not-yet-operational",
        "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25",
        "title": "Civil, defensive, and rights-preserving use boundary",
        "summary": "GShips may research safety, resilience, logistics, communications, recovery, and cyber defense only within explicit end-use, rights, and independent-review controls. Calling an activity defensive is never sufficient by itself.",
        "scopeTrigger": "Apply dual-use review before accepting or materially advancing customer, funder, collaborator, operational, procurement, or publication-sensitive work whose capability, data, end use, or transfer could reasonably enable a prohibited use. Public non-actionable education still follows prohibited-content and sensitive-publication controls.",
        "allowedInPrinciple": [
          "Safety engineering and independently assessed protection",
          "Resilience, graceful degradation, recovery, and disaster response",
          "Civil logistics, maintenance, communications, and knowledge continuity",
          "Cyber defense, secure software, incident response, and recovery",
          "Rights-preserving health, accessibility, ecology, education, and governance research"
        ],
        "prohibited": [
          "Identification, tracking, prioritization, or engagement of people or assets for force, weapons, repression, or offensive operations; safety navigation, astronomy, collision avoidance, search and rescue, and independently governed planetary defense are not prohibited by this clause",
          "Weapons command-and-control or targeting support",
          "Offensive access, persistence, exploitation, or destructive cyber payloads",
          "Mass surveillance, biometric repression, or political-control systems",
          "Autonomous force application",
          "Coercive reproductive, medical, genetic, disability, or civic control",
          "Nonconsensual experimentation or treating residents as research instruments"
        ],
        "reviewRequiredBeforeAnyRelevantWork": [
          "Customer, funder, collaborator, jurisdiction, beneficial-owner, and end-use screening",
          "Export-control and sanctions review by qualified counsel when applicable",
          "Written scope, allowed-use, prohibited-use, audit, termination, and incident clauses",
          "Independent stop-work authority with a named alternate and founder recusal",
          "Sensitive-publication and information-hazard review",
          "Whistleblowing, escalation, incident response, appeal, and anti-retaliation paths",
          "Aggregate transparency reporting that protects legitimate privacy and security"
        ],
        "currentBoundary": "No screening body, independent stop-work authority, contractual controls, or appeal body currently exists. Therefore no relevant customer, defense, dual-use, or operational engagement is authorized by this policy.",
        "changeControl": "Material changes require a dated public rationale, independent review, and may not be approved by the founder alone.",
        "correctionPath": "/corrections"
      }
    }
  ],
  "reviewContract": {
    "questions": [
      {
        "id": "question-1",
        "text": "Does the public synthesis accurately distinguish evidence, editorial interpretation, normative rules, current status, and unresolved uncertainty?",
        "required": true
      },
      {
        "id": "question-2",
        "text": "Are boundaries, decision rules, relationship language, privacy, access, and what-would-change conditions complete and understandable to affected publics?",
        "required": true
      },
      {
        "id": "question-3",
        "text": "Do linked records remain the source of entity facts and computed counts without being silently copied, ranked, endorsed, or promoted into stronger evidence?",
        "required": true
      }
    ],
    "exclusions": [
      "A synthesis review does not approve every linked record, computed count, preview row, or operational code path.",
      "Favorable wording review is not legal, medical, engineering, security, partnership, submission, launch, or governance authorization."
    ],
    "requestedScopeCodes": [
      "affected-public-rights",
      "ethics-planetary-protection",
      "governance-law-rights",
      "information-science",
      "visual-science-communication"
    ],
    "dispositions": [
      "approve",
      "revise",
      "contest",
      "reject",
      "recuse"
    ],
    "prohibitedInputs": [
      "private legal names or contact details",
      "identity documents or raw credential files",
      "accessibility or medical records",
      "confidential conflict evidence",
      "classified, export-controlled, proprietary, or exploit material"
    ],
    "freshness": {
      "maximumDecisionAgeFromFreezeDays": 180,
      "eventOccurrenceRule": "Not applicable to this packet family."
    },
    "completionRule": "Every primary record must receive the required number of valid, current-fingerprint approvals; every complementary scope group and required domain must be covered; any unresolved revise, contest, or reject disposition blocks publication.",
    "highConsequenceRule": "Named medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use conclusions require two distinct qualified independent humans covering complementary domain-method and rights/public-interest scopes."
  },
  "primaryRecords": [
    {
      "recordType": "page-synthesis",
      "recordId": "alternatives",
      "title": "Alternatives & decision gates",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "c8b8eadeeee3aa5141b6320b0131871ddffc97f2b7a3969a57ff36bb6eb6bbf4",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [
          "governance"
        ],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [
          "governance-law-rights"
        ],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "domain-method",
            "scopeClass": "domain-method",
            "oneOf": [
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "governance-law-rights"
            ]
          },
          {
            "id": "rights-public-interest",
            "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "alternatives",
        "packet": "alternatives",
        "route": "/alternatives",
        "title": "Alternatives & decision gates",
        "eyebrow": "Alternatives & decision gates",
        "heading": "Launch is only one outcome.",
        "description": "Compare probes, habitats, waiting, Earth resilience, biological alternatives, non-expansion, and explicit launch, wait, stop, and do-not-launch outcomes.",
        "authoredSections": [
          "comparison boundary",
          "overtaking argument",
          "noncompensatory vetoes",
          "mission-level system gate",
          "decision dossier",
          "launch, wait, stop, abandon, and do-not-launch outcomes"
        ],
        "noticesAndBoundaries": [
          "The pathways are not interchangeable engineering options or formal evidence grades.",
          "A benefit in one column cannot compensate for a failed rights, safety, ecological, or legitimacy veto."
        ],
        "decisionRules": [
          "A mission-level go requires every applicable capability gate and interface to pass.",
          "Prior approval cannot authorize a later irreversible architecture.",
          "Do not launch is a valid final outcome."
        ],
        "reviewBoundary": "Review the comparison frame, normative vetoes, dossier, and explicit outcomes separately from the ten pathway records and twenty system gates.",
        "whatWouldChange": "Plural rights, law, affected-public, ecological, planetary-protection, economic, or technical review could revise the comparison or add an alternative.",
        "linkedRecordKeys": [
          "alternative-pathway:*",
          "system:*",
          "academy-lesson:lesson-01-04",
          "academy-lesson:lesson-01-05"
        ],
        "rendererBinding": {
          "schemaVersion": "gships-page-renderer-binding-1",
          "status": "source-and-rendered-main-bound",
          "bindingFingerprint": "313c95d1cb2ae5ac6f9867bc94e69bd7220553677805b3b43beb416925d47693",
          "sourceAggregateSha256": "fc3a0a0bf781db22318e37aebd48bc8e4f27b75260bffbe910256503b8106a5e",
          "renderedRouteSurface": {
            "route": "/alternatives",
            "normalizedMainSha256": "7a8d03b7f4b307c18722a26b8185f591ce7bc59dba9eb49b2a59261614bbba88",
            "normalizedMainBytes": 16546
          }
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "earth-resilience-first",
      "title": "Earth resilience first",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "1e22b5b0d04d13ebc15ff2e6e51f1534bf240d32d7d6ba441c4961c7289244f3",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "earth-resilience-first",
        "name": "Earth resilience first",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Observed and demonstrated components; operational to major scale-up",
        "humanBurden": "No voyage burden; direct present beneficiaries",
        "reversibility": "High when projects are modular and locally governed",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Ordinary infrastructure, surveillance, cyber, and political risks still require controls",
        "decisiveGate": "Prefer when it closes a more urgent need or when space work lacks an additional Earthside benefit."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "telescopes-and-robotic-probes",
      "title": "Telescopes and robotic probes",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "3b4cb788f11577042c5786a8add6a43e25ed6fc947f00e26980dab42e69a24f9",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "telescopes-and-robotic-probes",
        "name": "Telescopes and robotic probes",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Operational observation plus demonstrated robotic exploration; interstellar probes remain breakthrough-dependent",
        "humanBurden": "No inherited human confinement or reproductive obligation",
        "reversibility": "High before launch; partial after launch; new probes can supersede old ones",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Autonomy, sensors, propulsion, beams, planetary defense, and surveillance can be dual use",
        "decisiveGate": "Characterize destinations and precursor environments before exposing people or ecosystems."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "solar-system-habitats",
      "title": "Solar System habitats",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "0dbc7115ef990565a3bbec31db32ab5bfd6736318e14a5b8527b4c21af12e284",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "solar-system-habitats",
        "name": "Solar System habitats",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Short-duration habitats are demonstrated; durable closure and settlement remain major scale-up",
        "humanBurden": "Voluntary adult participation can retain communication, rescue, resupply, return, and changing membership",
        "reversibility": "Higher than an interstellar commitment when exit and rescue remain real",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Habitat, nuclear, autonomy, mining, surveillance, and governance systems require review",
        "decisiveGate": "Use only as reversible testbeds with participant rights; never market an analog as consent for descendants."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "faster-propulsion-and-braking-research",
      "title": "Faster propulsion and braking research",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "7bcd32bf7239d7989f464b7daafe97ee5b7fe05a2b005020f25c2c86a7e98b99",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "faster-propulsion-and-braking-research",
        "name": "Faster propulsion and braking research",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Separate component demonstrations and models; no integrated crewed stellar transport",
        "humanBurden": "Can shorten exposure only if acceleration, braking, shielding, heat, reliability, and mass close together",
        "reversibility": "Research is reversible; launch infrastructure and destination commitment may not be",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "High-energy beams, nuclear systems, antimatter, and autonomous infrastructure have serious dual-use risk",
        "decisiveGate": "A faster cruise is not a mission until destination braking and all coupled systems are independently demonstrated."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "torpor-or-radical-longevity",
      "title": "Torpor or radical longevity",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "6d6c23af23dd9ab84a6c059ac02b35f728b60eb43cc391e95027c2b646248374",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "torpor-or-radical-longevity",
        "name": "Torpor or radical longevity",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Early research to breakthrough-dependent; no validated multidecade human state",
        "humanBurden": "May reduce active generations but creates continuous clinical care, consent, disability, failure, and revival burdens",
        "reversibility": "Low after irreversible biological intervention or departure",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Medical coercion, experimentation, access inequality, and control over incapacitated people",
        "decisiveGate": "Do not treat reduced headcount as reduced duty of care or a substitute for autonomous medicine."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "embryo-gamete-or-artificial-gestation",
      "title": "Embryo, gamete, or artificial-gestation proposals",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "c21cd8d1ccd07e1828daad2188ab824117fed1b625bdd61c73feff0f72ca6a04",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "embryo-gamete-or-artificial-gestation",
        "name": "Embryo, gamete, or artificial-gestation proposals",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "No known integrated path for autonomous gestation, childhood, care, culture, and legitimate authority",
        "humanBurden": "Transfers the mission to children who cannot consent and requires unprecedented robotic and social guardianship",
        "reversibility": "Very low after biological material is committed beyond rescue",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Reproductive control, eugenics, genetic selection, surveillance, and nonconsensual experimentation",
        "decisiveGate": "Reject any architecture that needs coercion, hereditary status, disability exclusion, or children as instruments."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "digital-minds-or-uploading",
      "title": "Digital minds or uploading",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "51f64d96af2eef1df46e810a6dd52c11d540593249f54a06c2584753911e2b05",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "digital-minds-or-uploading",
        "name": "Digital minds or uploading",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Proposed and contested; no evidence establishes continuity of personhood or a validated upload",
        "humanBurden": "Could change mass and habitat assumptions only by changing who or what travels",
        "reversibility": "Unknown; copying, deletion, identity, labor, and authority create new irreversibilities",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Mass surveillance, cognitive control, ownership, replication, impersonation, and cyber capture",
        "decisiveGate": "Do not use an unresolved identity claim to erase duties to biological people or claim human settlement."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "self-replicating-robotic-industry",
      "title": "Self-replicating robotic industry",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "29eb1be8cc0afff635bd8bfbdc8b35a72abaeb9d3d4139259e7168facb8fb510",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "self-replicating-robotic-industry",
        "name": "Self-replicating robotic industry",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Bounded autonomous mining, manufacturing, repair, and robotics exist separately; open-ended closure is not demonstrated",
        "humanBurden": "May prepare infrastructure without crew, but still affects environments and future governance",
        "reversibility": "Variable; uncontrolled replication or contamination can be difficult to recall",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Autonomous resource capture, replication, cyber compromise, weaponization, and planetary harm",
        "decisiveGate": "Require strict resource, replication, shutdown, verification, jurisdiction, and planetary-protection controls."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "wait-and-preserve-the-option",
      "title": "Wait and preserve the option",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "79c055222e67e778032b40568eebb5900cbbfb443fa42f8ee832fa531b68e8dc",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "wait-and-preserve-the-option",
        "name": "Wait and preserve the option",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Operational as a decision; benefits depend on what is learned or built meanwhile",
        "humanBurden": "Avoids premature inherited burdens while knowledge, legitimacy, and safer capabilities improve",
        "reversibility": "High when archives, institutions, and reversible research are maintained",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Delay can still entrench institutions or enable hazardous infrastructure without scrutiny",
        "decisiveGate": "Set explicit reopening dates and evidence thresholds; waiting is not passive neglect."
      }
    },
    {
      "recordType": "alternative-pathway",
      "recordId": "deliberate-non-expansion",
      "title": "Deliberate non-expansion",
      "publicPath": "/alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "fb5f361340e6ddad39689ebb2d72e570b8bfc8fae8e7feba48ec4d62d7afd133",
      "reviewRequirements": {
        "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1,
        "highConsequenceDomains": [],
        "requiredDomainCodes": [],
        "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [
          {
            "id": "bounded-competence",
            "scopeClass": "bounded-competence",
            "oneOf": [
              "affected-public-rights",
              "ethics-planetary-protection",
              "systems-engineering"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true
      },
      "referenceIds": [],
      "snapshot": {
        "id": "deliberate-non-expansion",
        "name": "Deliberate non-expansion",
        "evidenceAndReadiness": "Normative and politically available now",
        "humanBurden": "Avoids imposing a stellar settlement project; opportunity costs shift to Earth and Solar System choices",
        "reversibility": "A no-launch decision can be revisited, but destroyed ecosystems, rights, and budgets may not be restored",
        "dualUseAndMisuse": "Reduces some deployment risks but does not remove Earthside technology misuse",
        "decisiveGate": "Choose when rights, destination duties, public legitimacy, opportunity cost, or safer alternatives remain decisive."
      }
    }
  ],
  "linkedRecords": [
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "mission-architecture",
      "title": "Mission architecture & requirements",
      "publicPath": "/systems/mission-architecture",
      "recordFingerprint": "9cffe2c03337cdf1fe89b87afe2e8397f2e5fbc2704b8dbe4bc9d7691469b4e0"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "propulsion",
      "title": "Propulsion & trajectory",
      "publicPath": "/systems/propulsion",
      "recordFingerprint": "e22dde5ef50a3495a6760d8676ff6860722a1144edc5341c854aef8cb31203f0"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "power-thermal",
      "title": "Power generation & thermal rejection",
      "publicPath": "/systems/power-thermal",
      "recordFingerprint": "65ac1cd7d2d1ecd37d37799aacf926baab8f73317188c3573e99a0f767090caf"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "structures-shielding",
      "title": "Structures, habitats & shielding",
      "publicPath": "/systems/structures-shielding",
      "recordFingerprint": "377e5369b1f61601fca44935fdb803709c872e204f5b97ee6bf36ddac3c4942d"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "life-support",
      "title": "Air, water & waste life support",
      "publicPath": "/systems/life-support",
      "recordFingerprint": "708e96805aa5913e545741b896459f78e9f9115b83de4758eb6edf0cf72df3eb"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "ecology-food",
      "title": "Food, agriculture & closed ecology",
      "publicPath": "/systems/ecology-food",
      "recordFingerprint": "e04cdb3778ba805427428dab999904b8a2acf2b650b70b65dec892689e751cb6"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "health-medicine",
      "title": "Medicine, public health & human performance",
      "publicPath": "/systems/health-medicine",
      "recordFingerprint": "c5a0a79dc6997542128ab5531efc2d19b0c825fd0b3d972a5d42bb0faa49ccb3"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "reproduction-genetics",
      "title": "Reproduction, genetics & population",
      "publicPath": "/systems/reproduction-genetics",
      "recordFingerprint": "f61b7acf5663ad40872a2a6c84a25c779d917b780c22f20caa79b1aef16d2241"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "human-factors",
      "title": "Psychology, culture, education & meaning",
      "publicPath": "/systems/human-factors",
      "recordFingerprint": "d70b42291e00c8c2f264e071cfd59494aa1cf2f270abeff5fa1a9bc0df04cf57"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "governance-law",
      "title": "Governance, law, economics & rights",
      "publicPath": "/systems/governance-law",
      "recordFingerprint": "234fbdd0ae7a5b1356629360fbf5262b2a03e73dd4ada137ce12e6b81343c4fb"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "ai-autonomy",
      "title": "AI, LLMs, autonomy & digital twins",
      "publicPath": "/systems/ai-autonomy",
      "recordFingerprint": "28806d124fc870b3b3a457af967c5acdf047bcb5cca01431b50801a388f3e43d"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "cybersecurity",
      "title": "Cybersecurity, software assurance & recovery",
      "publicPath": "/systems/cybersecurity",
      "recordFingerprint": "48a0199de1d45db9fdb9aad2b20fcd4d219be2d336a58c2b4b44921d27a82a21"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "communications-navigation",
      "title": "Communications, navigation & knowledge",
      "publicPath": "/systems/communications-navigation",
      "recordFingerprint": "bb0e8da65781ed3621bd23b6c43adbfa0ba3c8b2d70b04cbbb2a7e6a048e0862"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "manufacturing-isru",
      "title": "Manufacturing, repair, recycling & ISRU",
      "publicPath": "/systems/manufacturing-isru",
      "recordFingerprint": "7846ec4b40072430c11582a0b68c8a2cedc7c3825cc2f96730b6b255b3cb778f"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "radiation-environment",
      "title": "Radiation, dust & the space environment",
      "publicPath": "/systems/radiation-environment",
      "recordFingerprint": "7dcbbc9c5c6b475b65e247c3e74c5f0d10d0f424332183c8840ac9d20cf716ee"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "assembly-logistics",
      "title": "Launch, assembly, logistics & supply chains",
      "publicPath": "/systems/assembly-logistics",
      "recordFingerprint": "0d8194a9390ffa72bdefb9f867bfdf37291f665934433320b017420954bddd7e"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "destinations-astrobiology",
      "title": "Destinations, astronomy & planetary protection",
      "publicPath": "/systems/destinations-astrobiology",
      "recordFingerprint": "ae2688b1a8c8954b32a5e9a5857aa7e9838327543318fa862fac0e1aec42e3bc"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "analogs-verification",
      "title": "Analogs, testbeds, simulation & verification",
      "publicPath": "/systems/analogs-verification",
      "recordFingerprint": "2713a7b5c12845ef5b7bc0c2a10f637072749782824b5aa7d51bcc21f7feda02"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "ethics-alternatives",
      "title": "Ethics, alternatives & decision gates",
      "publicPath": "/systems/ethics-alternatives",
      "recordFingerprint": "26d441fab037ca844574808a36eeb2af90f2fefe25bb571d8c8793c3249dd9ec"
    },
    {
      "recordType": "system",
      "recordId": "institutions-workforce",
      "title": "Institutions, capital, standards & workforce",
      "publicPath": "/systems/institutions-workforce",
      "recordFingerprint": "182659f3d9f465916bf309fc9d81cc51d77458050bc6b5040e7b4d44a54f1368"
    }
  ],
  "referenceSnapshots": [],
  "packetFingerprint": "aeaa7aaecf647c371fd044dff812b89adbb9c00d9a38d2b5f38aeabfe6871c22"
}
