# GShips offline review-notes worksheet Status: blank notes companion; not a decision bundle Packet: `systems:analogs-verification` Packet SHA-256: `bae96613b377565339057a41fd9d5d149416676148e517f6e317470f52776396` Release: `public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14` Source commit: `3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0` This readable worksheet is for local notes only. It cannot satisfy the closed decision-bundle schema and is not input to the validator. Use the fingerprinted JSON template for any future structured decision. This worksheet appoints nobody and records no completed review. Do not put identity documents, private contact data, medical or accessibility records, confidential conflict evidence, controlled material, or exploit details here. Keep notes offline until a separately authorized private handoff exists. ## Reviewer declaration Opaque public reviewer ID: Public label: Controlled scope codes: Qualification basis: Independence status and bounded basis: Conflict public summary: Compensation status and public summary: AI assistance and human-verification statement: Publication consent selections: ## 1. Analogs, testbeds, simulation & verification - Record: `system:analogs-verification` - Record SHA-256: `2713a7b5c12845ef5b7bc0c2a10f637072749782824b5aa7d51bcc21f7feda02` - Public record: /systems/analogs-verification - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 2. Worldship capability must climb a transparent proof ladder from components to integrated analogs to autonomous space habitats; no single analog validates the whole mission. - Record: `claim:claim-18-01` - Record SHA-256: `77117d77c9cb8341e62b6814aa513f9a9eac87ced6ba1c1437f0579b4b8f8bd6` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-01 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 3. ISS, HERA, CHAPEA, Concordia, Biosphere 2, MELiSSA, Lunar Palace, and habitat laboratories each test different slices. - Record: `claim:claim-18-02` - Record SHA-256: `c1a07e65803cf9368db208d581c604d0e94ff34fea2b3b68403d7853f0234cad` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-02 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 4. Digital twins, fault injection, model-based engineering, hardware-in-the-loop, and human-in-the-loop testing are mature methods. - Record: `claim:claim-18-03` - Record SHA-256: `155abde0cbd28ea009869744d5db36e99448071933f1b328bb3d7c22da5f5989` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-03 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 5. Negative results often provide the most useful evidence about hidden couplings and institutional behavior. - Record: `claim:claim-18-04` - Record SHA-256: `7b8eb5cc95f3650171295810b6eaf85ce179417cb51777aa3e47bea5f57b5c82` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-04 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 6. Short duration, small crew, Earth support, 1 g, and easy rescue limit transfer from present analogs. - Record: `claim:claim-18-05` - Record SHA-256: `68d0ab4d0f7a73ef2d7348837ebe78606482c52da7fbcaaebd6f505ef57bc7ee` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-05 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 7. There is no shared benchmark for material closure, autonomous recovery, governance stress, knowledge loss, or multi-domain faults. - Record: `claim:claim-18-06` - Record SHA-256: `67af42c08f79394648284ce0aca656c9ce54d2917a442daf6981191e87cd5176` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-06 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 8. Organizations can distort analog outcomes when branding, schedules, or funding discourage transparent failure reporting. - Record: `claim:claim-18-07` - Record SHA-256: `6053d5f4182a4f14c41d72362c2666f977ce78329b7283964dfd4393ab8cdb91` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-07 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (governance-law-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 9. Open stress tests improve resilience of buildings, utilities, hospitals, farms, and emergency organizations. - Record: `claim:claim-18-08` - Record SHA-256: `f3305bf7d399c58cb708c68fc7ae4d530b4085cba8815c5d53ef41b8ca54b683` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-08 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 10. Shared datasets and reference scenarios reduce duplicated effort across research programs. - Record: `claim:claim-18-09` - Record SHA-256: `1ab59dc4e143f90b62d98f70ba7fa3d5adf2af4a72eabd61711cf1f3724c444d` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-09 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 11. Every claimed capability must identify its environment, duration, scale, intervention, failure history, evidence boundary, and next harder test. - Record: `claim:claim-18-10` - Record SHA-256: `e298befeb55ba21ccee84294ad8676ec7ae82e52d1ebe456ee4ed7f52d056f49` - Public record: /claims/claim-18-10 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, security-assurance, systems-engineering) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 12. Open Science - Record: `claim-source:src-cd-nasa-open-science` - Record SHA-256: `97a09c788cd8ed1efb6c0d704d9d40a3e55f7c8eaadce2c2a993375041fbc8ae` - Public record: https://science.nasa.gov/open-science/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 13. Isolation studies in Antarctica - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-esa-concordia` - Record SHA-256: `43ec053dddc5b835520a04b8f3d66f34c7369efd300eb39ca9b22f3d2be3eb1b` - Public record: https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Exploration/Isolation_studies_in_Antarctica - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 14. 2024 NASA Technology Taxonomy - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nasa-taxonomy` - Record SHA-256: `87d47de6cbbc1a4457881fef14a44e22fd463bc17a64dbdf794f22e208fc7915` - Public record: https://www.nasa.gov/otps/2024-nasa-technology-taxonomy/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 15. The Science and Practice of Team Science - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nasem-team-science-2025` - Record SHA-256: `a3fab330d13623cf46ab40800fadb9ded54218cbf943b34c6e94b01f384bf5ba` - Public record: https://nap.nationalacademies.org/resource/29043/interactive/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 16. The NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nist-csf-2` - Record SHA-256: `dc71e2ac06d05e0a7a6c032f0df743d1fcf357ae95d866a7f755df060bddb6fe` - Public record: https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/CSWP/NIST.CSWP.29.pdf - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: