# GShips offline review-notes worksheet Status: blank notes companion; not a decision bundle Packet: `systems:ecology-food` Packet SHA-256: `9c9192728befdc0e7b23ebb30dde44c11a81f488b4f82f39e7b787211f7d8fe4` Release: `public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14` Source commit: `3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0` This readable worksheet is for local notes only. It cannot satisfy the closed decision-bundle schema and is not input to the validator. Use the fingerprinted JSON template for any future structured decision. This worksheet appoints nobody and records no completed review. Do not put identity documents, private contact data, medical or accessibility records, confidential conflict evidence, controlled material, or exploit details here. Keep notes offline until a separately authorized private handoff exists. ## Reviewer declaration Opaque public reviewer ID: Public label: Controlled scope codes: Qualification basis: Independence status and bounded basis: Conflict public summary: Compensation status and public summary: AI assistance and human-verification statement: Publication consent selections: ## 1. Food, agriculture & closed ecology - Record: `system:ecology-food` - Record SHA-256: `e04cdb3778ba805427428dab999904b8a2acf2b650b70b65dec892689e751cb6` - Public record: /systems/ecology-food - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (closed-loop-systems, ecology-food) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 2. A ship must cultivate calories, nutrients, microbial function, ecological resilience, and cultural meaning—not merely grow salad. - Record: `claim:claim-06-01` - Record SHA-256: `6cd250468cc1565afdb538f3d763cd2908f6a80e85b164c7f31b13154b96900f` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-01 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food, governance-law-rights); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 3. Crop chambers, microbial biomanufacturing experiments, controlled agriculture, and closed-ecology analogs provide distinct evidence at different scales, durations, environments, and achieved functions; they should not be treated as one demonstration class. - Record: `claim:claim-06-02` - Record SHA-256: `ed451f95a94793bfc1e6caa8b59f3685ba776f74ab0226050dd9e7617f4efa5f` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-02 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 4. ESA MELiSSA develops regenerative life-support compartments and progressive integration; it has not demonstrated a completed multigenerational closed ecology. - Record: `claim:claim-06-03` - Record SHA-256: `938203392bb074580142f4840b871db855d36d8a146a85c11c2fc905309797e5` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-03 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 5. Biosphere 2 and Lunar Palace report different, boundary-specific closure results and also expose chemical, material, operational, and microbial couplings. - Record: `claim:claim-06-04` - Record SHA-256: `e7d63d0d2c5104ad4a887cb47cf5fab768e3c1e6771a1d33eb028e45a92ff3ff` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-04 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 6. A complete, nutritionally adequate, culturally acceptable diet has not been regenerated in space. - Record: `claim:claim-06-05` - Record SHA-256: `2602f6efb563176bd998858c038bc187373bbb1b257f7f19c47b9f6644cda5e1` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-05 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 7. Crop disease, pollinator loss, loss of required microbial function, pathogen increase, reduced diversity, instability, salt accumulation, and harmful genetic change can propagate across tightly coupled loops. - Record: `claim:claim-06-06` - Record SHA-256: `e9387e67cc30c0ba95913690c511334a36e89fb61023fb3e5048898dd4d86d67` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-06 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 8. Small chambers do not scale linearly to neighborhoods with children, animals, varied diets, and changing population. - Record: `claim:claim-06-07` - Record SHA-256: `fac2d87e0c1fc11f00ca7756cc8e7904dc6189a57fd424666352d762a203b204` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-07 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 9. Controlled agriculture, microbial protein, circular nutrients, and resilient seed systems may improve food security when energy, labor, safety, and supply-chain burdens are also demonstrated. - Record: `claim:claim-06-08` - Record SHA-256: `376925a8219ef14367bd4ed89d3febe9009e6a21ac0a3d4d981b7e0e17ac0847` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-08 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food, governance-law-rights); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 10. Ecological digital twins and transparent closure metrics can strengthen greenhouses and urban water-food systems. - Record: `claim:claim-06-09` - Record SHA-256: `2ea7133f2ef2bb79036ca926b9fe8ac4b8f3f4b5890e8701d9ffce9e14417558` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-09 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (closed-loop-systems, defensive-cyber-safety, ecology-food, governance-law-rights); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 11. Operate an integrated hybrid ecology through multi-season failures while measuring every essential element and publishing negative results. - Record: `claim:claim-06-10` - Record SHA-256: `1db35cc6b407b64c9ccbd3ff8e01324cdd38685bf8fcc37ac5c65c4866f4595f` - Public record: /claims/claim-06-10 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (clinical-health, closed-loop-systems, ecology-food, governance-law-rights); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 12. Standard for Models and Simulations - Record: `claim-source:src-ak-nasa-models-simulations-7009b` - Record SHA-256: `8f6e834f09954fef302c7b3ecfb02347690909841cabd58f172c74eac18e2b7f` - Public record: https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/nasa/nasa-std-7009 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 13. Security and Trust Considerations for Digital Twin Technology - Record: `claim-source:src-ak-nist-digital-twin-8356` - Record SHA-256: `500f59e2c271844456dfb2599f2dd243c83fe149ff6345a5de803fee3cdc300e` - Public record: https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.IR.8356 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 14. Oxygen Loss in Biosphere 2 - Record: `claim-source:src-ca-biosphere2-oxygen-loss` - Record SHA-256: `2c2aa6020a740e7a5a4a4754520260383e57681e755f4ddd5b7227891240cdbd` - Public record: https://doi.org/10.1029/94EO00285 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 15. Trends, Insights, and Future Prospects for Production in Controlled Environment Agriculture and Agrivoltaics Systems - Record: `claim-source:src-ca-usda-controlled-agriculture` - Record SHA-256: `4fea0fe4fdc3cb2dea2c0f49e1736657ae2a929c42d78f51aa5809be74648c4e` - Public record: https://ers.usda.gov/publications/108220 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 16. Biosphere 2 Research Initiatives - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-biosphere-research` - Record SHA-256: `523e23d81d59cfa4d14167595f5af57faf702a3e11b1b084304a79c271f71f4f` - Public record: https://biosphere2.org/research/research-initiatives - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 17. Space Crops - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-nasa-space-crops` - Record SHA-256: `bffdd1d3ec431d47e3a5415bd002e15baa6c17aa905ca9979e3cc4188c3ca1de` - Public record: https://science.nasa.gov/biological-physical/space-crops/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 18. Our Relationship to Microbes on the International Space Station - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-nasa-station-microbiology` - Record SHA-256: `2207e8c2f3f4cb48027596a92b472976d693e7e9c80ef04cc5ce5b4f5b81cccb` - Public record: https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/benefits/our-relationship-to-microbes-on-iss - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 19. Vegetable Production System (Veggie) - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-nasa-veggie` - Record SHA-256: `ed2e84afacac288e49660067ee80842dba2e030a0bf195c7cfc3d4b8ecb17d13` - Public record: https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/experiments/explorer/Investigation.html?#id=374 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 20. Thriving in Space: Ensuring the Future of Biological and Physical Sciences Research - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-nasem-thriving` - Record SHA-256: `82198fd7579f8b695b177fd5d98aa75a4417aeb0d305010d13ff63ced421c50a` - Public record: https://www.nationalacademies.org/read/26750/chapter/8 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 21. Sustainable Healthy Diets: Guiding Principles - Record: `claim-source:src-ce-who-sustainable-diets` - Record SHA-256: `386f240bb076bad3a7625a314db8a1ee091905de7394b9b20ff99388ba4661a4` - Public record: https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241516648 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: