{ "schemaVersion": "gships-review-packet-1", "packetId": "systems:human-factors", "stableId": "human-factors", "family": "systems", "slug": "human-factors", "title": "Psychology, culture, education & meaning", "status": "prepared-human-review-not-started", "release": { "releaseId": "public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14", "sourceCommit": "3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0", "corpusGeneratedAt": "2026-07-25", "frozenAt": "2026-07-26T22:50:50.000Z", "canonicalOrigin": "https://gships.dammonburden.com" }, "paths": { "human": "/review/systems/human-factors", "family": "/review/systems", "packet": "/review-packets/systems/human-factors.b803a11ab9ed60a3.json", "decisionTemplate": "/review-packets/systems/human-factors.b803a11ab9ed60a3.decision-template.json", "worksheet": "/review-packets/systems/human-factors.b803a11ab9ed60a3.worksheet.md", "byFingerprint": "/review-packets/by-fingerprint/b803a11ab9ed60a329d9accf9d0528d02888c340d11c7896aa33433cf3d17472.json" }, "boundary": "Prepared review packet; human review has not started. This packet is not a completed review, endorsement, reviewer appointment, partnership, or authorization to act.", "governingPolicies": [ { "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001", "version": "0.1.0", "path": "/editorial-policy", "recordType": "governing-policy", "fingerprint": "1f6a1f823e8bfe891b6a707c5dce2ee2337c0bb7d915b48d6060ca82b8da1b47", "snapshot": { "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001", "version": "0.1.0", "status": "foundation-policy-controls-not-yet-staffed", "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25", "title": "Editorial governance and independent review", "publisher": "GShips Project", "maintainer": "Dammon Burden", "publisherInterest": "The maintainer intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work. No entity, outside funding, customer, sponsor, or indexed-organization relationship currently exists.", "currentBoundary": "No independent domain reviewer or review council is currently appointed. Foundation records and outlines may not be represented as independently reviewed.", "reviewerSelection": [ "Publish the reviewer’s name, relevant credentials or lived expertise, review scope, compensation status, and declared conflicts with consent.", "Select for the actual claim domain rather than general prestige; include affected-community and disability-led expertise where rights or access are involved.", "Do not treat an employee, investor, customer, sponsor, source author, or directly supervised collaborator as independent for the affected claim." ], "reviewProcess": [ "Provide the exact claim, sources, locators, assumptions, counterevidence, transfer limits, and proposed evidence dimensions.", "Record approve, revise, contest, or reject at claim level; silence and event attendance never count as review.", "Publish material minority findings and the editor’s reasoned response.", "High-consequence medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use claims require two qualified independent reviewers with complementary scopes.", "A reviewer may recuse at any time; unresolved conflicts or missing expertise block the reviewed label." ], "appealAndCorrection": [ "A correction receives a reference identifier and triage record; safety-critical allegations receive priority.", "A material editorial decision may be appealed to a reviewer not involved in the original decision once such a panel exists.", "Substantive reversals, unresolved disputes, and removed conclusions receive a dated public record that protects reporter privacy.", "No sponsor, customer, founder, or reviewer may purchase, suppress, or unilaterally assign an evidence grade." ], "publicationGate": "Public 1.0 requires named review coverage across every Academy track, documented high-consequence two-person review, a material-corrections log, reviewer conflict records, and an operating appeal path.", "correctionPath": "/corrections" } }, { "id": "policy-dual-use-001", "version": "0.1.0", "path": "/dual-use", "recordType": "governing-policy", "fingerprint": "81637e2849f9c0866d23f7174eb9a2ce522b86313167ebf5022fca122d6e506c", "snapshot": { "id": "policy-dual-use-001", "version": "0.1.0", "status": "planned-controls-not-yet-operational", "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25", "title": "Civil, defensive, and rights-preserving use boundary", "summary": "GShips may research safety, resilience, logistics, communications, recovery, and cyber defense only within explicit end-use, rights, and independent-review controls. Calling an activity defensive is never sufficient by itself.", "scopeTrigger": "Apply dual-use review before accepting or materially advancing customer, funder, collaborator, operational, procurement, or publication-sensitive work whose capability, data, end use, or transfer could reasonably enable a prohibited use. Public non-actionable education still follows prohibited-content and sensitive-publication controls.", "allowedInPrinciple": [ "Safety engineering and independently assessed protection", "Resilience, graceful degradation, recovery, and disaster response", "Civil logistics, maintenance, communications, and knowledge continuity", "Cyber defense, secure software, incident response, and recovery", "Rights-preserving health, accessibility, ecology, education, and governance research" ], "prohibited": [ "Identification, tracking, prioritization, or engagement of people or assets for force, weapons, repression, or offensive operations; safety navigation, astronomy, collision avoidance, search and rescue, and independently governed planetary defense are not prohibited by this clause", "Weapons command-and-control or targeting support", "Offensive access, persistence, exploitation, or destructive cyber payloads", "Mass surveillance, biometric repression, or political-control systems", "Autonomous force application", "Coercive reproductive, medical, genetic, disability, or civic control", "Nonconsensual experimentation or treating residents as research instruments" ], "reviewRequiredBeforeAnyRelevantWork": [ "Customer, funder, collaborator, jurisdiction, beneficial-owner, and end-use screening", "Export-control and sanctions review by qualified counsel when applicable", "Written scope, allowed-use, prohibited-use, audit, termination, and incident clauses", "Independent stop-work authority with a named alternate and founder recusal", "Sensitive-publication and information-hazard review", "Whistleblowing, escalation, incident response, appeal, and anti-retaliation paths", "Aggregate transparency reporting that protects legitimate privacy and security" ], "currentBoundary": "No screening body, independent stop-work authority, contractual controls, or appeal body currently exists. Therefore no relevant customer, defense, dual-use, or operational engagement is authorized by this policy.", "changeControl": "Material changes require a dated public rationale, independent review, and may not be approved by the founder alone.", "correctionPath": "/corrections" } } ], "reviewContract": { "questions": [ { "id": "question-1", "text": "Does each evidence basis, readiness level, confidence level, rationale, and locator match the frozen sources?", "required": true }, { "id": "question-2", "text": "Are dependencies, failure modes, precursors, unknowns, Earthside benefits, and the stop gate technically and ethically bounded?", "required": true }, { "id": "question-3", "text": "Which conclusion should be approved, revised, contested, rejected, or recused from at its current fingerprint?", "required": true } ], "exclusions": [ "A system packet is not a complete spacecraft design, feasibility proof, safety case, or launch authorization.", "Context sources do not become direct support unless the record says so with an exact locator and relation." ], "requestedScopeCodes": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "human-factors", "information-science", "systems-engineering" ], "dispositions": [ "approve", "revise", "contest", "reject", "recuse" ], "prohibitedInputs": [ "private legal names or contact details", "identity documents or raw credential files", "accessibility or medical records", "confidential conflict evidence", "classified, export-controlled, proprietary, or exploit material" ], "freshness": { "maximumDecisionAgeFromFreezeDays": 365, "eventOccurrenceRule": "Not applicable to this packet family." }, "completionRule": "Every primary record must receive the required number of valid, current-fingerprint approvals; every complementary scope group and required domain must be covered; any unresolved revise, contest, or reject disposition blocks publication.", "highConsequenceRule": "Named medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use conclusions require two distinct qualified independent humans covering complementary domain-method and rights/public-interest scopes." }, "primaryRecords": [ { "recordType": "system", "recordId": "human-factors", "title": "Psychology, culture, education & meaning", "publicPath": "/systems/human-factors", "recordFingerprint": "d70b42291e00c8c2f264e071cfd59494aa1cf2f270abeff5fa1a9bc0df04cf57", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "human-factors" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "slug": "human-factors", "name": "Psychology, culture, education & meaning", "shortName": "Human life", "index": 9, "thesis": "A survivable vessel is not automatically a livable society; people need privacy, agency, family, play, culture, dissent, nature, meaningful work, and the ability to remake inherited institutions.", "currentState": [ "ISS, HERA, CHAPEA, Mars500, Concordia, submarines, and polar stations provide partial evidence about isolation and confined operations.", "Spaceflight experience consistently values private quarters, shared meals, controllable lighting, recreation, personalization, and social choice.", "Archives and AI can preserve explicit information, while embodied skills still require apprenticeship and practice." ], "unknowns": [ "No analog reproduces birth, childhood, aging, irreversible separation, ecological closure, and governance across generations.", "Mission dissent, grief, boredom, family change, religious plurality, and cultural evolution cannot be solved by crew selection.", "Minimum volume standards do not establish the spatial requirements of a healthy civil community." ], "earthBenefits": [ "Human-centered extreme-environment design improves hospitals, control rooms, shelters, vessels, and remote workplaces.", "Knowledge-continuity methods strengthen institutions facing retirement, disaster, and technological change." ], "dependencies": [ "structures-shielding", "governance-law", "ai-autonomy" ], "gate": "Demonstrate that residents can retain privacy, education, cultural choice, political agency, and meaningful non-mission lives under scarcity.", "sources": [ { "title": "NASA Behavioral Health Risk", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/esdmd/hhp/behavioral-health-risk/", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" }, { "title": "NASA CHAPEA", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/chapea/about-chapea/", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" }, { "title": "ESA Concordia", "url": "https://explorationscience.esa.int/platforms/concordia/", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" } ], "failureModes": [ "Isolation, sleep disruption, conflict, trauma, monotony, or status inequality degrades cooperation and safety.", "Critical tacit skills disappear despite a nominally complete archive and training curriculum." ], "precursors": [ "Polar, submarine, expedition, offshore, and Mars-analog studies with transparent participant protections.", "Intergenerational education, apprenticeship, conflict mediation, and mental-health systems tested in real communities." ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-01", "title": "A survivable vessel is not automatically a livable society; people need privacy, agency, family, play, culture, dissent, nature, meaningful work, and the ability to remake inherited institutions.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-01", "recordFingerprint": "1cfa440fec7d5d75387fbd82470b37cc0c6a97ff082696febfcd3a4b660c1a20", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "governance", "intergenerational-rights" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-po-nasa-hera", "src-po-nasa-hidh", "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "src-po-un-crpd", "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "src-po-unicef-crc" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-01", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "thesis", "statementRef": { "field": "thesis" }, "statement": "A survivable vessel is not automatically a livable society; people need privacy, agency, family, play, culture, dissent, nature, meaningful work, and the ability to remake inherited institutions.", "statementFingerprint": "9ac1fd4378045420e87d35f176378d615d890cf87bed910a262a1ed01b587302", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "normative", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Human-rights instruments and human-system guidance support treating privacy, agency, accessibility, culture, participation, development, and humane living conditions as requirements beyond physiological survival. Bounded isolation analogs do not validate a multigenerational society." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "locator": "Articles 17–19, 21–22, and 25–27, privacy, expression, association, participation, and minority culture.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unicef-crc", "locator": "Articles 12–17 and 28–31, voice, privacy, information, education, culture, rest, play, and participation.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-un-crpd", "locator": "Articles 3–5, 9, 19, 21, 24–25, and 29–30, autonomy, accessibility, inclusion, and participation.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "locator": "Articles 1–5, cultural diversity, pluralism, participation, cultural rights, and the human-rights boundary.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "locator": "Sections 3–4 and habitability and human-interface guidance for human-system integration.", "relation": "context-only" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hera", "locator": "Program description and research scope for isolation, autonomy, communication, human factors, and behavioral health.", "relation": "context-only" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no entity, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Independent rights, disability, childhood, cultural, and human-factors review could revise the listed requirements, but survival-only evidence would not establish a livable or legitimate society.", "highConsequence": [ "governance", "intergenerational-rights" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-02", "title": "ISS, HERA, CHAPEA, Mars500, Concordia, submarines, and polar stations provide partial evidence about isolation and confined operations.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-02", "recordFingerprint": "21026d2777670cdb61316e3783435b99e91830c6a186587929b2dd12d33f2166", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "behavioral-health", "governance", "intergenerational-rights", "labor", "privacy" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "src-po-nasa-hera" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-02", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 0 }, "statement": "ISS, HERA, CHAPEA, Mars500, Concordia, submarines, and polar stations provide partial evidence about isolation and confined operations.", "statementFingerprint": "6cae339f2ea0a956c613f225c2534a58ab360dc5d03069b551918a37661b71a2", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "strong", "rationale": "The cited programs conduct or document bounded operations and studies involving selected adults, confinement, isolation, communication, workload, and behavioral health. Their duration, population, environment, Earth support, and exit conditions limit transfer to a multigenerational society." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "locator": "Adult crew, habitat, mission duration, Mars-surface stressors, research goals, and Earth-based simulation boundary.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hera", "locator": "Facility and research scope for isolation, communication, autonomy, human factors, behavioral health, and medicine.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "locator": "Exploration behavioral-health risk, contributing factors, evidence base, countermeasures, and research boundaries.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "locator": "Current crew human-factors, habitability, environmental-health, and mission-system requirements and scope.", "relation": "scope-boundary" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no analog facility, research participant, customer, sponsor, NASA, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Representative long-duration evidence including diverse families, children, disability, aging, leadership turnover, ecological scarcity, meaningful exit, and independent rights oversight would expand—but not erase—the analog boundary.", "highConsequence": [ "governance", "privacy", "labor", "behavioral-health", "intergenerational-rights" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-03", "title": "Spaceflight experience consistently values private quarters, shared meals, controllable lighting, recreation, personalization, and social choice.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-03", "recordFingerprint": "a5e8cdabdc38ca29f9767f8c5bc72453546a112378e5b1207c90c999e89a0205", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "culture", "disability", "governance", "labor", "privacy" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "src-po-nasa-hidh", "src-po-ohchr-iccpr" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-03", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Spaceflight experience consistently values private quarters, shared meals, controllable lighting, recreation, personalization, and social choice.", "statementFingerprint": "204c49f56606551f5b4da4cd3b5730754196624855847c84d512a643147461e9", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "NASA risk, design, and standards material supports privacy, sleep, controllable environmental conditions, recreation, personalization, and social considerations in current crewed contexts. The claim does not establish universal preferences or a civil habitat's quantitative requirements." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "locator": "Isolation, confinement, sleep, workload, team, behavioral-health, evidence, and mitigation scope.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "locator": "Habitability, private and communal volume, lighting, acoustics, sleep, recreation, personalization, workload, and interface guidance.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "locator": "Human factors, habitability, environmental health, accommodations, and crew-interface requirements within current mission scope.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "locator": "Articles 17–19, 21–22, and 25–27, privacy, expression, association, participation, equality, and minority culture.", "relation": "context-only" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no habitat operator, standards authority, resident body, customer, sponsor, NASA, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Diverse-population research showing that different spatial, sensory, temporal, and social-control variables better predict sleep, health, privacy, conflict, belonging, and recovery would revise the listed design priorities.", "highConsequence": [ "privacy", "culture", "disability", "labor", "governance" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-04", "title": "Archives and AI can preserve explicit information, while embodied skills still require apprenticeship and practice.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-04", "recordFingerprint": "25b9d07988ac21500f3b4cf88998d80a47d1f3d11f8f17d2fbde9a2daf0499ce", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "culture", "education", "governance", "labor", "surveillance" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-ilo-r208", "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-04", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 2 }, "statement": "Archives and AI can preserve explicit information, while embodied skills still require apprenticeship and practice.", "statementFingerprint": "e2a2fd1cde22691685736bb186da503190d5d9501176354413b9c952cefa1da1", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Archival standards and AI guidance address explicit information, representation, retrieval, and risk, while apprenticeship guidance treats competence as structured on- and off-the-job learning with mentoring and assessment. No source validates centuries of integrated continuity." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "locator": "Sections 2–4, designated communities, representation information, information packages, preservation functions, and responsibilities.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "locator": "Definitions and provisions on structured on- and off-the-job learning, qualified supervision, learning outcomes, assessment, recognition, safety, and rights.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "locator": "Confabulation, information-integrity, privacy, provenance, human-AI configuration, and knowledge-limit risks and actions.", "relation": "limitation" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "locator": "Operational account of archival documentation, specialist reasoning, diagnosis, recovery, and Earth-based commanding.", "relation": "context-only" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work and could benefit from knowledge-assurance products; no archive, school, software vendor, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Longitudinal evidence that explicit records or validated AI alone preserve representative physical, clinical, civic, and cultural capabilities without supervised practice would narrow the apprenticeship requirement.", "highConsequence": [ "education", "labor", "culture", "surveillance", "governance" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-05", "title": "No analog reproduces birth, childhood, aging, irreversible separation, ecological closure, and governance across generations.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-05", "recordFingerprint": "023c147667a7e12306f02273179136a1b90aef2ee23be0fcaf77ba073fc40e97", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "child-rights", "disability", "family", "governance", "intergenerational-rights" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "src-po-nasa-hera", "src-po-unicef-crc" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-05", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 0 }, "statement": "No analog reproduces birth, childhood, aging, irreversible separation, ecological closure, and governance across generations.", "statementFingerprint": "95462339882eca758f4a1505056be88d542adb84ff1e7f64fbe35ec48617d383", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "unknown", "readiness": "no-known-path", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "The reviewed analogs involve selected adult cohorts, bounded duration, Earth support, and possible termination. They do not reproduce birth, childhood, aging, irreversible separation, ecological closure, and constitutional succession together." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "locator": "Adult crew, habitat, mission duration, stressors, research aims, and Earth simulation and support boundary.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hera", "locator": "Bounded adult analog facility and research scope for isolation, communication, autonomy, human factors, and medicine.", "relation": "scope-boundary" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "locator": "Current exploration behavioral-health risk, evidence population, mitigation, and research scope.", "relation": "scope-boundary" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unicef-crc", "locator": "Articles 2–6, 12–17, 23–24, and 28–31, child development, agency, privacy, disability, health, education, culture, and play.", "relation": "limitation" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no analog facility, family research program, child participant, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A voluntary, independently governed longitudinal habitat program spanning families, childhood, aging, disability, ecological failures, leadership succession, cultural change, and real exit would narrow—but not close—the validation gap.", "highConsequence": [ "child-rights", "family", "disability", "intergenerational-rights", "governance" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-06", "title": "Mission dissent, grief, boredom, family change, religious plurality, and cultural evolution cannot be solved by crew selection.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-06", "recordFingerprint": "f62ecf082dd861980f039bce7d97c73fb62277696645d385e8b3646409126c08", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "culture", "family", "governance", "intergenerational-rights", "privacy" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-06", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Mission dissent, grief, boredom, family change, religious plurality, and cultural evolution cannot be solved by crew selection.", "statementFingerprint": "edcba1f01a3e5de620b938de2e21f8c9ab2d35fbfde7bd06d65e6d9c5a357ac2", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "proposed", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Behavioral-health evidence can inform selection and support for bounded adult missions, while cultural and civil rights protect plural belief, expression, association, and change. Those sources do not support eliminating grief, dissent, family change, or cultural evolution through selection." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "locator": "Behavioral-health and performance risk, team, isolation, confinement, selection-adjacent mitigation, and research boundaries.", "relation": "scope-boundary" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "locator": "Articles 1–6, cultural diversity, pluralism, creativity, participation, cultural rights, and human-rights boundary.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "locator": "Articles 1–3 and 11–15, living heritage, transmission, safeguarding, and community participation.", "relation": "context-only" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "locator": "Articles 17–19, 21–22, and 25–27, privacy, belief, expression, association, participation, equality, and minority culture.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no cultural authority, crew-selection program, rights-holder mandate, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Evidence that a rights-compatible selection or support method reliably prevents a specific bounded harm could narrow that risk, but it would not authorize suppression of grief, dissent, family change, religion, or cultural evolution.", "highConsequence": [ "culture", "family", "privacy", "governance", "intergenerational-rights" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-07", "title": "Minimum volume standards do not establish the spatial requirements of a healthy civil community.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-07", "recordFingerprint": "b3f9b6e1bf95ff37d4fd1277170d89638ae338f4c0bee7c8cbbb4695824161a0", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "child-rights", "disability", "family", "labor", "privacy" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "src-po-nasa-hidh", "src-po-un-crpd" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-07", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 2 }, "statement": "Minimum volume standards do not establish the spatial requirements of a healthy civil community.", "statementFingerprint": "5342b12dfbae616570761c8142c3a1bff455d29e023db99e472a152ef42aac06", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "unknown", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Current human-system standards and handbooks define requirements for mission crews and environments, while disability rights expose broader access needs. They do not establish lifetime civil-community volume across families, culture, privacy, work, disability, and aging." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "locator": "Human factors, habitability, environmental-health, accommodation, crew-interface, and mission-scope requirements.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "locator": "Habitability, net volume, privacy, communal space, anthropometry, lighting, acoustics, workload, and interface guidance.", "relation": "scope-boundary" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-un-crpd", "locator": "Articles 5, 9, 19–21, 24–27, and 29–30, accessibility, inclusion, information, education, health, work, culture, and participation.", "relation": "scope-boundary" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no habitat operator, standards authority, customer, sponsor, disability organization, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Diverse-body, family, cultural, work, privacy, and emergency studies in full-scale long-duration habitats could establish bounded spatial requirements and change the current unknown assessment.", "highConsequence": [ "disability", "privacy", "family", "child-rights", "labor" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-08", "title": "Human-centered extreme-environment design improves hospitals, control rooms, shelters, vessels, and remote workplaces.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-08", "recordFingerprint": "2195c2f660231bdd6071329d7a195727984543083e37a529e5055cabff65ff61", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "disability", "medical", "privacy", "spacecraft-safety" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "clinical-health" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "clinical-health", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "src-hp-usab-ada", "src-po-nasa-hidh" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-08", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "earth benefit", "statementRef": { "field": "earthBenefits", "index": 0 }, "statement": "Human-centered extreme-environment design improves hospitals, control rooms, shelters, vessels, and remote workplaces.", "statementFingerprint": "60e5913d1058bf3b0884bbc1477d163aba8b0bbde258f3e0e87fb42b589c3361", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "proposed", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "tentative", "rationale": "NASA and accessibility standards provide operational methods for human-system integration, habitability, workload, controls, alarms, lighting, acoustics, privacy, translation, and assisted egress. Transfer to hospitals, control rooms, shelters, vessels, and remote workplaces is plausible but the cited corpus does not demonstrate better outcomes across every named setting." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "locator": "Sections 3–4 and guidance on human-system integration, anthropometry, habitability, workload, controls, alarms, lighting, acoustics, maintainability, and evaluation.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "locator": "Sections 6–8 on environmental health, habitability, crew interfaces, translation, assisted egress, controls, lighting, maintenance, and human-in-the-loop testing.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-hp-usab-ada", "locator": "Chapters 2–7 on accessible routes, doors, clear space, reach, operable parts, communication, sanitation, alarms, and dwelling units.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "GShips' Earth-first positioning benefits from asserting terrestrial transfer, and a future habitat-assurance venture could serve remote facilities; the cross-sector outcome claim is therefore graded tentative and no NASA or facility relationship is implied." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Independent comparative evaluations in each claimed setting must show improvements in error, workload, sleep, accessibility, evacuation, exposure, recovery, and resident or operator control. Null results, new fire or toxicity burdens, surveillance harms, or systematic exclusion of disabled users would narrow the transfer claim.", "highConsequence": [ "medical", "disability", "privacy", "spacecraft-safety" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-09", "title": "Knowledge-continuity methods strengthen institutions facing retirement, disaster, and technological change.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-09", "recordFingerprint": "2cf7bf5e28a01800ff2e2745e052d1e4cde2c5358ed35ae28f2ee78ff1cb02d8", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "culture", "education", "governance", "labor" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-cu-ilo-r208", "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-09", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "earth benefit", "statementRef": { "field": "earthBenefits", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Knowledge-continuity methods strengthen institutions facing retirement, disaster, and technological change.", "statementFingerprint": "07868638925f3d7c4981811919dc451d0b04c1b125d46844cca099a81953cd25", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "proposed", "readiness": "operational", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Archival preservation, structured apprenticeship, and long-lived mission records provide established methods relevant to organizational succession. The claimed improvement depends on repeated recovery, teaching quality, worker rights, and institutional adoption." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "locator": "Sections 2–4, designated communities, representation information, information packages, preservation planning, and archival responsibilities.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "locator": "Structured on- and off-the-job learning, agreements, inclusion, qualified supervision, assessment, recognition, safety, compensation, and rights.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "locator": "Operational example of long-lived documentation, institutional expertise, diagnosis, recovery, and delayed commanding.", "relation": "context-only" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work and could benefit from knowledge-continuity products; no archive, apprenticeship program, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Comparative longitudinal evidence showing that documented teach-back, archival recovery, and structured succession do not improve capability retention after retirement, disaster, leadership change, or technology turnover would weaken this claim.", "highConsequence": [ "education", "labor", "governance", "culture" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-09-10", "title": "Demonstrate that residents can retain privacy, education, cultural choice, political agency, and meaningful non-mission lives under scarcity.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-09-10", "recordFingerprint": "2afa854282f82f5c3bad22fe6807614a45d4ec20ade998a411fbf4ebc166d2f6", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "child-rights", "disability", "governance", "intergenerational-rights", "labor" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "governance-law-rights" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "governance-law-rights", "human-factors" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "accessibility-disability-justice", "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-gr-ohchr-icescr", "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "src-po-un-crpd", "src-po-unicef-crc" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-09-10", "systemSlug": "human-factors", "kind": "decision gate", "statementRef": { "field": "gate" }, "statement": "Demonstrate that residents can retain privacy, education, cultural choice, political agency, and meaningful non-mission lives under scarcity.", "statementFingerprint": "d05347258b7d9fc7e28935555686a8b05f18d322fee34abe39793e174f3c3a2e", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "normative", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Current human-rights instruments support privacy, education, culture, family, disability inclusion, participation, and meaningful work as more than survival amenities. No analog demonstrates these conditions under multigenerational scarcity and irreversible separation." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "locator": "Articles 17–19, 21–22, and 25–27, privacy, expression, belief, association, participation, equality, and minority culture.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-gr-ohchr-icescr", "locator": "Articles 6–7 and 12–15, meaningful and just work, health, education, science, and cultural life.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unicef-crc", "locator": "Articles 12–17 and 28–31, youth voice, privacy, information, education, culture, rest, play, and participation.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-po-un-crpd", "locator": "Articles 9, 12, 19, 21, 24–25, and 27–30, accessibility, agency, inclusion, work, culture, and political participation.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-09-1", "core-09-2", "core-09-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work; no habitat operator, resident body, customer, sponsor, or partner relationship currently exists." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Representative voluntary habitat evidence showing that a different independently reviewed livability standard better predicts durable privacy, agency, education, culture, meaningful life, and remedy under scarcity could revise this gate.", "highConsequence": [ "governance", "intergenerational-rights", "disability", "labor", "child-rights" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "title": "Quality Apprenticeships Recommendation, 2023 (No. 208)", "publicPath": "https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/r208-quality-apprenticeships-recommendation-2023", "recordFingerprint": "7f0ffeba7f122098cb810e1767cffa060cd7dec7286cd0ebbe89aefd76423fe7", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "title": "Quality Apprenticeships Recommendation, 2023 (No. 208)", "authors": [ "International Labour Organization" ], "publisher": "International Labour Organization", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/r208-quality-apprenticeships-recommendation-2023", "kind": "international-labour-recommendation", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Recommendation text on structured learning, agreements, inclusion, worker participation, safety, compensation, mentoring, assessment, qualifications, and apprentices' rights." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "title": "Behavioral Health and Performance Risk", "publicPath": "https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/esdmd/hhp/behavioral-health-risk/", "recordFingerprint": "970f047ce483c880fa4f9e2a62f8c76e450505246a2526920c347d787aed0790", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "title": "Behavioral Health and Performance Risk", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/esdmd/hhp/behavioral-health-risk/", "kind": "active-human-research-risk-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Current NASA exploration-risk description covering isolation, confinement, workload, sleep, team dynamics, evidence, countermeasures, and research boundaries." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "title": "Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", "publicPath": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/convention", "recordFingerprint": "89a4961afffb8284dbc6d52645def81ae52d515f1cbd4c7a8a6cbaac6eab4967", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "title": "Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", "authors": [ "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization" ], "publisher": "UNESCO", "year": 2003, "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/convention", "kind": "international-cultural-heritage-convention", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Convention text concerning living intangible heritage, safeguarding, identification, transmission, community participation, international cooperation, and scope." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "title": "Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System", "publicPath": "https://ccsds.org/searchpubs/entry/3054/", "recordFingerprint": "d130fb645b4838a8e446a7a861ad942052dcb493afd6bd7c431bd9e863999212", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "title": "Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System", "authors": [ "Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems" ], "publisher": "CCSDS", "year": 2024, "url": "https://ccsds.org/searchpubs/entry/3054/", "kind": "space-data-systems-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "OAIS information packages, representation information, designated communities, preservation planning, access, and archive-management functions." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-po-nasa-hera", "title": "About HERA", "publicPath": "https://www.nasa.gov/hera-about-hera/", "recordFingerprint": "8490a3730a3243421965cce84085974065985ac05199b4f186abecd92fddcee7", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-nasa-hera", "title": "About HERA", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/hera-about-hera/", "kind": "active-analog-program-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Facility, isolation, communication, autonomy, behavioral-health, human-factors, and medical research scope for bounded analog missions." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "title": "NASA's Voyager 1 Revives Backup Thrusters Before Command Pause", "publicPath": "https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/voyager/2025/05/14/nasas-voyager-1-revives-backup-thrusters-before-command-pause/", "recordFingerprint": "4d8cedab7b127f1a1f99ac87470dea72eb1205508a04872abc608e390f20c40f", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "title": "NASA's Voyager 1 Revives Backup Thrusters Before Command Pause", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory" ], "publisher": "NASA Science", "year": 2025, "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/voyager/2025/05/14/nasas-voyager-1-revives-backup-thrusters-before-command-pause/", "kind": "operational-mission-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Bounded evidence of long-lived robotic spacecraft operations, diagnosis, recovery, delayed commanding, and reliance on Earth-based expertise." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "title": "UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity", "publicPath": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/unesco-universal-declaration-cultural-diversity", "recordFingerprint": "1e209fa385a777b02447ded3515d46df4c4bc542afea84b0716c07ef9123bf8a", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "title": "UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity", "authors": [ "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization" ], "publisher": "UNESCO", "year": 2001, "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/unesco-universal-declaration-cultural-diversity", "kind": "international-normative-instrument", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Normative principles connecting cultural diversity, pluralism, participation, cultural rights, and the non-derogation of human rights." } } ], "linkedRecords": [], "referenceSnapshots": [ { "sourceId": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "7f0ffeba7f122098cb810e1767cffa060cd7dec7286cd0ebbe89aefd76423fe7", "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-ilo-r208", "title": "Quality Apprenticeships Recommendation, 2023 (No. 208)", "authors": [ "International Labour Organization" ], "publisher": "International Labour Organization", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/r208-quality-apprenticeships-recommendation-2023", "kind": "international-labour-recommendation", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Recommendation text on structured learning, agreements, inclusion, worker participation, safety, compensation, mentoring, assessment, qualifications, and apprentices' rights." } }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "970f047ce483c880fa4f9e2a62f8c76e450505246a2526920c347d787aed0790", "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "title": "Behavioral Health and Performance Risk", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/esdmd/hhp/behavioral-health-risk/", "kind": "active-human-research-risk-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Current NASA exploration-risk description covering isolation, confinement, workload, sleep, team dynamics, evidence, countermeasures, and research boundaries." } }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "a89cf33d6910d1fa7ea76ea80056e3d8183e34cd4fdac88150984787a399ee97", "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-nasa-std-3001-v2", "title": "NASA Space Flight Human-System Standard Volume 2: Human Factors, Habitability, and Environmental Health", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2025, "url": "https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/NASA/NASA-STD-3001_VOL_2", "kind": "active-human-spaceflight-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-26", "version": "E", "documentDate": "2025-05-01", "status": "ACTIVE", "reviewDue": "2028-09-15", "scopeNote": "NASA-STD-3001 Volume 2 Revision E provides current requirements for human factors, habitability, environmental health, crew interfaces, accommodations, and human-system integration for human-rated systems and spacefaring crews. It is a requirements standard, not evidence that a diverse civil population or any particular habitat has met those requirements." } }, { "sourceId": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "89a4961afffb8284dbc6d52645def81ae52d515f1cbd4c7a8a6cbaac6eab4967", "snapshot": { "id": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "title": "Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", "authors": [ "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization" ], "publisher": "UNESCO", "year": 2003, "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/convention", "kind": "international-cultural-heritage-convention", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Convention text concerning living intangible heritage, safeguarding, identification, transmission, community participation, international cooperation, and scope." } }, { "sourceId": "src-gr-ohchr-icescr", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "b7cad62fcb85435a8fa350ceb02b5a8fa151d78e8cfe17d85bd594fcd62471f4", "snapshot": { "id": "src-gr-ohchr-icescr", "title": "International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights", "authors": [ "United Nations General Assembly" ], "publisher": "Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights", "year": 1966, "url": "https://2covenants.ohchr.org/About-ICESCR.html", "kind": "international-human-rights-treaty", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Treaty rights concerning work, just conditions, social protection, family, adequate living standards, health, education, science, and culture." } }, { "sourceId": "src-hp-usab-ada", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "bb5e4fa2bd2f9e7997c5fb32271fb9383e9b5b61b60dd693880d37cf848f0a6f", "snapshot": { "id": "src-hp-usab-ada", "title": "ADA Accessibility Standards", "authors": [ "United States Access Board" ], "publisher": "United States Access Board", "year": 2010, "url": "https://www.access-board.gov/ada/", "kind": "official-terrestrial-accessibility-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Terrestrial requirements for accessible routes, doors, clear spaces, reach, controls, communication features, sanitation, alarms, and dwelling units; altered-gravity transfer requires validation." } }, { "sourceId": "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "6cd53784e44d0b1aa513a944a0cea3c6ec9be3c0cea643aa29258f41114bab1b", "snapshot": { "id": "src-pa-nasa-chapea", "title": "About CHAPEA", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/humans-in-space/chapea/about-chapea/", "kind": "active-analog-program-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Habitat, schedule, stressors, research goals, and stated limits of NASA's Mars surface simulation." } }, { "sourceId": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "4066eeecafdc810d0ad828dd8bd53e4a05daeb6b03dde36fafe581976402cb59", "snapshot": { "id": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1", "kind": "government-risk-management-profile", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Generative-AI governance, provenance, evaluation, security, confabulation, privacy, and incident disclosure." } }, { "sourceId": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "d130fb645b4838a8e446a7a861ad942052dcb493afd6bd7c431bd9e863999212", "snapshot": { "id": "src-pn-ccsds-oais", "title": "Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System", "authors": [ "Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems" ], "publisher": "CCSDS", "year": 2024, "url": "https://ccsds.org/searchpubs/entry/3054/", "kind": "space-data-systems-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "OAIS information packages, representation information, designated communities, preservation planning, access, and archive-management functions." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hera", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "8490a3730a3243421965cce84085974065985ac05199b4f186abecd92fddcee7", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-nasa-hera", "title": "About HERA", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/hera-about-hera/", "kind": "active-analog-program-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Facility, isolation, communication, autonomy, behavioral-health, human-factors, and medical research scope for bounded analog missions." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "27126bb23e74265b0bffdf1bdccbfe500b4f5e9db79e9814f869e8948c24adc6", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-nasa-hidh", "title": "Human Integration Design Handbook", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2014, "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/human-integration-design-handbook-revision-1.pdf", "kind": "institutional-human-systems-handbook", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Human-system integration, habitability, accessibility-adjacent design, workload, interfaces, task design, and human-performance guidance." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "4d8cedab7b127f1a1f99ac87470dea72eb1205508a04872abc608e390f20c40f", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "title": "NASA's Voyager 1 Revives Backup Thrusters Before Command Pause", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory" ], "publisher": "NASA Science", "year": 2025, "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/voyager/2025/05/14/nasas-voyager-1-revives-backup-thrusters-before-command-pause/", "kind": "operational-mission-record", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Bounded evidence of long-lived robotic spacecraft operations, diagnosis, recovery, delayed commanding, and reliance on Earth-based expertise." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "63bc50215f4323c55575cda693efd870f6d909b529eef34a800c00adc128f98e", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-ohchr-iccpr", "title": "International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights", "authors": [ "United Nations General Assembly" ], "publisher": "Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights", "year": 1966, "url": "https://2covenants.ohchr.org/About-ICCPR.html", "kind": "international-human-rights-treaty", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Treaty rights concerning life, privacy, expression, belief, association, political participation, minorities, equality, and effective remedy." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-un-crpd", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "950c11dd1f7fcf399f65feddd7b3964ab056ceb84dd5e658259c468aaad992c7", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-un-crpd", "title": "Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities", "authors": [ "United Nations General Assembly" ], "publisher": "United Nations", "year": 2006, "url": "https://www.un.org/esa/socdev/enable/rights/convtexte.htm", "kind": "international-human-rights-treaty", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Treaty text on dignity, autonomy, accessibility, legal capacity, inclusion, health, education, culture, and political participation." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "1e209fa385a777b02447ded3515d46df4c4bc542afea84b0716c07ef9123bf8a", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "title": "UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity", "authors": [ "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization" ], "publisher": "UNESCO", "year": 2001, "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/unesco-universal-declaration-cultural-diversity", "kind": "international-normative-instrument", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Normative principles connecting cultural diversity, pluralism, participation, cultural rights, and the non-derogation of human rights." } }, { "sourceId": "src-po-unicef-crc", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "5bdae8a7100ea191caad9293c738bb6cd277320ab47e1142ae827954b50853fd", "snapshot": { "id": "src-po-unicef-crc", "title": "Convention on the Rights of the Child", "authors": [ "United Nations General Assembly" ], "publisher": "UNICEF", "year": 1989, "url": "https://www.unicef.org/child-rights-convention/convention-text", "kind": "international-human-rights-treaty", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Treaty text on children's best interests, identity, expression, privacy, education, health, development, culture, protection, and participation." } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-cu-ilo-r208", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "18925f3e254dfd3bb221179687869ff53b7364eaf7a8f30ae11baa188f35bba4", "snapshot": { "title": "Quality Apprenticeships Recommendation, 2023 (No. 208)", "url": "https://www.ilo.org/resource/other/r208-quality-apprenticeships-recommendation-2023", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-cu-ilo-r208" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "8c30743ea472e2ac887607d6fe7abc40efee1266a2e3dcffb02078d6a9be8611", "snapshot": { "title": "Behavioral Health and Performance Risk", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/esdmd/hhp/behavioral-health-risk/", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-cu-nasa-behavioral-health" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "5de25bebed8ae6eaf7cfb08cf8b75ff6732cd5f7f96b35c776f02cc97df03717", "snapshot": { "title": "Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage", "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/convention", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-cu-unesco-intangible-heritage" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-pn-ccsds-oais", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "e2587427409d84524c131f9546c9586db5192bbcd81a3d706ef2ec24a6735022", "snapshot": { "title": "Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System", "url": "https://ccsds.org/searchpubs/entry/3054/", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-pn-ccsds-oais" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-po-nasa-hera", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "2bdf31e3483cf154fa0b224a4f4f58e6704db4c29c6cb35baf3c7159a6a99bad", "snapshot": { "title": "About HERA", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/hera-about-hera/", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-po-nasa-hera" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "d4986d2acf54cc4d38715f61f176133a5e0a6d8b086ebe299ebec9687fa14550", "snapshot": { "title": "NASA's Voyager 1 Revives Backup Thrusters Before Command Pause", "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/voyager/2025/05/14/nasas-voyager-1-revives-backup-thrusters-before-command-pause/", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-po-nasa-voyager-thrusters" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "7db27067b87ffd6ab861c9cc8ee778f37385f2d61de3463937d0546f10c47a5b", "snapshot": { "title": "UNESCO Universal Declaration on Cultural Diversity", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/unesco-universal-declaration-cultural-diversity", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-po-unesco-cultural-diversity" } } ], "packetFingerprint": "b803a11ab9ed60a329d9accf9d0528d02888c340d11c7896aa33433cf3d17472" }