# GShips offline review-notes worksheet Status: blank notes companion; not a decision bundle Packet: `systems:institutions-workforce` Packet SHA-256: `d79e33c128f5f4da8b9da34129116b8d3e789865d15051be0ff6fa0db2e7cc5d` Release: `public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14` Source commit: `3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0` This readable worksheet is for local notes only. It cannot satisfy the closed decision-bundle schema and is not input to the validator. Use the fingerprinted JSON template for any future structured decision. This worksheet appoints nobody and records no completed review. Do not put identity documents, private contact data, medical or accessibility records, confidential conflict evidence, controlled material, or exploit details here. Keep notes offline until a separately authorized private handoff exists. ## Reviewer declaration Opaque public reviewer ID: Public label: Controlled scope codes: Qualification basis: Independence status and bounded basis: Conflict public summary: Compensation status and public summary: AI assistance and human-verification statement: Publication consent selections: ## 1. Institutions, capital, standards & workforce - Record: `system:institutions-workforce` - Record SHA-256: `182659f3d9f465916bf309fc9d81cc51d77458050bc6b5040e7b4d44a54f1368` - Public record: /systems/institutions-workforce - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 2. The enduring product is an institution that can learn, publish failure, transfer leadership, fund useful modules, and coordinate many organizations without pretending one company can vertically integrate a civilization. - Record: `claim:claim-20-01` - Record SHA-256: `827e964c87481699e350c161167088452b1c36d96285ca284f925f2e35ad0f2c` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-01 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (governance-law-rights, institution-building); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 3. CERN, ISS, the Human Genome Project, Voyager, standards bodies, and open-science communities demonstrate durable coordination patterns. - Record: `claim:claim-20-02` - Record SHA-256: `d0fa5a742cee6e2dae4da8476786f8644cee4b59d9bc1c039a1f7c680425ad03` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-02 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 4. NASA, ESA, DOE, universities, national labs, professional societies, startups, and analog facilities already own many enabling capabilities. - Record: `claim:claim-20-03` - Record SHA-256: `a70b9ffa91f2b35eecac74a26f48e0badafeee9c934186059ea15bd68e2e39dd` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-03 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 5. SBIR/STTR, user facilities, Space Act Agreements, prizes, philanthropy, venture capital, and paid studies provide staged funding paths. - Record: `claim:claim-20-04` - Record SHA-256: `deb1849794e646250119b3cf8d320e63e6e705c56f24bd2c681f15ad5ed03911` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-04 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 6. No procurement market for generation ships was identified in the reviewed corpus; any near-term product needs a separately validated customer and measurable Earth or Solar System outcome. - Record: `claim:claim-20-05` - Record SHA-256: `88a7262686e0cb6d7c9f94158edce798c0044a7b2f0356721b7a9928dbd6e48e` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-05 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 7. Open knowledge, public trust, proprietary product work, defense funding, export controls, and sponsor influence require explicit firewalls. - Record: `claim:claim-20-06` - Record SHA-256: `471e63c021974d31d5e871549f8cae2a51cf51dfcd96f5cdcabd6ff3442b4f43` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-06 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (dual-use-risk, governance-law-rights, institution-building); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 8. Charismatic-founder dependence is incompatible with a century-scale mission. - Record: `claim:claim-20-07` - Record SHA-256: `facd0bea2a655bd3f62da9e5f338b863bcc39bb5145ae4ec35b3b69ecc5cd02c` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-07 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (governance-law-rights, institution-building); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 9. Open standards, shared test infrastructure, transparent evidence, and leadership succession improve any long-horizon public-interest program. - Record: `claim:claim-20-08` - Record SHA-256: `c5bf0192c7b4612b0f9000804751a2f691237c261e1dfc3aeb4316df044514e3` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-08 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (governance-law-rights, institution-building); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 10. A trusted capability map helps researchers, students, funders, and customers find useful work now. - Record: `claim:claim-20-09` - Record SHA-256: `f4a6be7207212595e175b2c4684a70913518ff2897fd7949e8d9a0d4955a29e5` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-09 - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (affected-public-rights, governance-law-rights, institution-building) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 11. Fund only work with a real near-term beneficiary, a measurable capability gap, reversible tests, transparent conflicts, and an independent review path. - Record: `claim:claim-20-10` - Record SHA-256: `4b1369389b84c13a8bef231751cb0741fa4b13c4793e87cc8942a847f6b3684a` - Public record: /claims/claim-20-10 - Minimum independent approvals: 2 - Required scope groups: domain-method (dual-use-risk, governance-law-rights, institution-building); rights-public-interest (affected-public-rights) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 12. Partnerships - Record: `claim-source:src-cd-nasa-partnerships` - Record SHA-256: `9f9cb5a3fcb6b5b3024569b8c222d5c4477c3fcd7404118a64448418e0f100e6` - Public record: https://www.nasa.gov/partnerships/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 13. Office of Science - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-doe-office-science` - Record SHA-256: `12f7364376353fdf9b20312d393fa084654aa38d880813935bf252b74943a5aa` - Public record: https://www.energy.gov/science/office-science - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 14. NASA SBIR/STTR Program - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nasa-sbir` - Record SHA-256: `9f336a52ea6d8e6a633301ad953ab7ba2cb86f26189181a43cb2027700ad8e07` - Public record: https://www.nasa.gov/sbir_sttr/ - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 15. Enhancing the Effectiveness of Team Science - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nasem-team-science-2015` - Record SHA-256: `3e2a454dc0d40c40147cf73a69135649d0abb076552b726be83041ede4041c54` - Public record: https://nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/19007/enhancing-the-effectiveness-of-team-science - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: ## 16. Research Infrastructure - Record: `claim-source:src-pa-nsf-infrastructure` - Record SHA-256: `f162274f5f17a2b7f5ea4dfcf0ee2f85d339c1db799e736fc46fb88f9b1e777c` - Public record: https://www.nsf.gov/od/ori/research-infrastructure - Minimum independent approvals: 1 - Required scope groups: bounded-competence (information-science) Disposition: [ ] approve [ ] revise [ ] contest [ ] reject [ ] recuse Bounded scope: Rationale: Evidence source ID, exact locator, and finding: Proposed correction or recusal reason: What would change this decision: