{ "schemaVersion": "gships-review-packet-1", "packetId": "systems:manufacturing-isru", "stableId": "manufacturing-isru", "family": "systems", "slug": "manufacturing-isru", "title": "Manufacturing, repair, recycling & ISRU", "status": "prepared-human-review-not-started", "release": { "releaseId": "public-alpha-2026-07-26-research-visuals-r14", "sourceCommit": "3eb036fce3d711336c8c605625895e8a2e799ab0", "corpusGeneratedAt": "2026-07-25", "frozenAt": "2026-07-26T22:50:50.000Z", "canonicalOrigin": "https://gships.dammonburden.com" }, "paths": { "human": "/review/systems/manufacturing-isru", "family": "/review/systems", "packet": "/review-packets/systems/manufacturing-isru.6bd3638d8bcb9c53.json", "decisionTemplate": "/review-packets/systems/manufacturing-isru.6bd3638d8bcb9c53.decision-template.json", "worksheet": "/review-packets/systems/manufacturing-isru.6bd3638d8bcb9c53.worksheet.md", "byFingerprint": "/review-packets/by-fingerprint/6bd3638d8bcb9c531c2a88c88d61cda6b02aa94ec4267b86b89a06fbc1f1f3d8.json" }, "boundary": "Prepared review packet; human review has not started. This packet is not a completed review, endorsement, reviewer appointment, partnership, or authorization to act.", "governingPolicies": [ { "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001", "version": "0.1.0", "path": "/editorial-policy", "recordType": "governing-policy", "fingerprint": "1f6a1f823e8bfe891b6a707c5dce2ee2337c0bb7d915b48d6060ca82b8da1b47", "snapshot": { "id": "policy-editorial-governance-001", "version": "0.1.0", "status": "foundation-policy-controls-not-yet-staffed", "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25", "title": "Editorial governance and independent review", "publisher": "GShips Project", "maintainer": "Dammon Burden", "publisherInterest": "The maintainer intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work. No entity, outside funding, customer, sponsor, or indexed-organization relationship currently exists.", "currentBoundary": "No independent domain reviewer or review council is currently appointed. Foundation records and outlines may not be represented as independently reviewed.", "reviewerSelection": [ "Publish the reviewer’s name, relevant credentials or lived expertise, review scope, compensation status, and declared conflicts with consent.", "Select for the actual claim domain rather than general prestige; include affected-community and disability-led expertise where rights or access are involved.", "Do not treat an employee, investor, customer, sponsor, source author, or directly supervised collaborator as independent for the affected claim." ], "reviewProcess": [ "Provide the exact claim, sources, locators, assumptions, counterevidence, transfer limits, and proposed evidence dimensions.", "Record approve, revise, contest, or reject at claim level; silence and event attendance never count as review.", "Publish material minority findings and the editor’s reasoned response.", "High-consequence medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use claims require two qualified independent reviewers with complementary scopes.", "A reviewer may recuse at any time; unresolved conflicts or missing expertise block the reviewed label." ], "appealAndCorrection": [ "A correction receives a reference identifier and triage record; safety-critical allegations receive priority.", "A material editorial decision may be appealed to a reviewer not involved in the original decision once such a panel exists.", "Substantive reversals, unresolved disputes, and removed conclusions receive a dated public record that protects reporter privacy.", "No sponsor, customer, founder, or reviewer may purchase, suppress, or unilaterally assign an evidence grade." ], "publicationGate": "Public 1.0 requires named review coverage across every Academy track, documented high-consequence two-person review, a material-corrections log, reviewer conflict records, and an operating appeal path.", "correctionPath": "/corrections" } }, { "id": "policy-dual-use-001", "version": "0.1.0", "path": "/dual-use", "recordType": "governing-policy", "fingerprint": "81637e2849f9c0866d23f7174eb9a2ce522b86313167ebf5022fca122d6e506c", "snapshot": { "id": "policy-dual-use-001", "version": "0.1.0", "status": "planned-controls-not-yet-operational", "adoptedForFoundation": "2026-07-25", "title": "Civil, defensive, and rights-preserving use boundary", "summary": "GShips may research safety, resilience, logistics, communications, recovery, and cyber defense only within explicit end-use, rights, and independent-review controls. Calling an activity defensive is never sufficient by itself.", "scopeTrigger": "Apply dual-use review before accepting or materially advancing customer, funder, collaborator, operational, procurement, or publication-sensitive work whose capability, data, end use, or transfer could reasonably enable a prohibited use. Public non-actionable education still follows prohibited-content and sensitive-publication controls.", "allowedInPrinciple": [ "Safety engineering and independently assessed protection", "Resilience, graceful degradation, recovery, and disaster response", "Civil logistics, maintenance, communications, and knowledge continuity", "Cyber defense, secure software, incident response, and recovery", "Rights-preserving health, accessibility, ecology, education, and governance research" ], "prohibited": [ "Identification, tracking, prioritization, or engagement of people or assets for force, weapons, repression, or offensive operations; safety navigation, astronomy, collision avoidance, search and rescue, and independently governed planetary defense are not prohibited by this clause", "Weapons command-and-control or targeting support", "Offensive access, persistence, exploitation, or destructive cyber payloads", "Mass surveillance, biometric repression, or political-control systems", "Autonomous force application", "Coercive reproductive, medical, genetic, disability, or civic control", "Nonconsensual experimentation or treating residents as research instruments" ], "reviewRequiredBeforeAnyRelevantWork": [ "Customer, funder, collaborator, jurisdiction, beneficial-owner, and end-use screening", "Export-control and sanctions review by qualified counsel when applicable", "Written scope, allowed-use, prohibited-use, audit, termination, and incident clauses", "Independent stop-work authority with a named alternate and founder recusal", "Sensitive-publication and information-hazard review", "Whistleblowing, escalation, incident response, appeal, and anti-retaliation paths", "Aggregate transparency reporting that protects legitimate privacy and security" ], "currentBoundary": "No screening body, independent stop-work authority, contractual controls, or appeal body currently exists. Therefore no relevant customer, defense, dual-use, or operational engagement is authorized by this policy.", "changeControl": "Material changes require a dated public rationale, independent review, and may not be approved by the founder alone.", "correctionPath": "/corrections" } } ], "reviewContract": { "questions": [ { "id": "question-1", "text": "Does each evidence basis, readiness level, confidence level, rationale, and locator match the frozen sources?", "required": true }, { "id": "question-2", "text": "Are dependencies, failure modes, precursors, unknowns, Earthside benefits, and the stop gate technically and ethically bounded?", "required": true }, { "id": "question-3", "text": "Which conclusion should be approved, revised, contested, rejected, or recused from at its current fingerprint?", "required": true } ], "exclusions": [ "A system packet is not a complete spacecraft design, feasibility proof, safety case, or launch authorization.", "Context sources do not become direct support unless the record says so with an exact locator and relation." ], "requestedScopeCodes": [ "information-science", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ], "dispositions": [ "approve", "revise", "contest", "reject", "recuse" ], "prohibitedInputs": [ "private legal names or contact details", "identity documents or raw credential files", "accessibility or medical records", "confidential conflict evidence", "classified, export-controlled, proprietary, or exploit material" ], "freshness": { "maximumDecisionAgeFromFreezeDays": 365, "eventOccurrenceRule": "Not applicable to this packet family." }, "completionRule": "Every primary record must receive the required number of valid, current-fingerprint approvals; every complementary scope group and required domain must be covered; any unresolved revise, contest, or reject disposition blocks publication.", "highConsequenceRule": "Named medical, reproductive, nuclear, radiation, cybersecurity, governance, and dual-use conclusions require two distinct qualified independent humans covering complementary domain-method and rights/public-interest scopes." }, "primaryRecords": [ { "recordType": "system", "recordId": "manufacturing-isru", "title": "Manufacturing, repair, recycling & ISRU", "publicPath": "/systems/manufacturing-isru", "recordFingerprint": "7846ec4b40072430c11582a0b68c8a2cedc7c3825cc2f96730b6b255b3cb778f", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "slug": "manufacturing-isru", "name": "Manufacturing, repair, recycling & ISRU", "shortName": "Industry", "index": 14, "thesis": "A worldship needs a circular industrial ecosystem, not a large 3D printer; the factory must maintain the factory and qualify every replacement.", "currentState": [ "Polymer printing, sample metal printing, welding experiments, robotic servicing, and limited recycling have flown.", "Ground programs are advancing regolith excavation, oxygen/metals extraction, large structures, and autonomous manufacturing cells.", "No end-to-end autonomous chain exists from mixed waste or ore to a certified installed critical part." ], "unknowns": [ "Semiconductors, bearings, seals, lubricants, catalysts, precision optics, tools, and calibration standards remain vitamin inputs.", "Recycled feedstock can hide contamination and property drift without extensive metrology and nondestructive evaluation.", "Century-scale process equipment must itself be repaired using locally available processes and knowledge." ], "earthBenefits": [ "Autonomous spares planning, repair cells, material passports, and recycled-feedstock assurance benefit remote industry.", "Design-for-disassembly and circular qualification reduce waste and supply-chain dependence." ], "dependencies": [ "power-thermal", "ai-autonomy", "assembly-logistics" ], "gate": "Operate an integrated factory cell through tool wear, sensor drift, contaminated feedstock, missing specialists, and injected cyber faults.", "sources": [ { "title": "NASA 2025 ISAM State of Play", "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250008988", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" }, { "title": "NASA In-Space Manufacturing Portfolio Plan", "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250004020", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" }, { "title": "GAO ISAM assessment", "url": "https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-25-107555.pdf", "kind": "Primary or institutional source" } ], "failureModes": [ "Feedstock contamination, metrology drift, missing tooling, or an irreplaceable machine stops multiple repair chains.", "A printed part matches shape but not material properties, certification evidence, or lifetime under the real load." ], "precursors": [ "Orbital servicing, station additive manufacturing, terrestrial remanufacturing, and repairable-product standards.", "Lunar and asteroid resource demonstrations that publish full excavation, beneficiation, energy, and spares balances." ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-01", "title": "A worldship needs a circular industrial ecosystem, not a large 3D printer; the factory must maintain the factory and qualify every replacement.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-01", "recordFingerprint": "cb5955efd2e2a07f7344c5f98a8d1377ccf8694551e92b479554ce7a7e9c9b06", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "src-im-nasa-std-6030" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-01", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "thesis", "statementRef": { "field": "thesis" }, "statement": "A worldship needs a circular industrial ecosystem, not a large 3D printer; the factory must maintain the factory and qualify every replacement.", "statementFingerprint": "cb05b5af3f99f6e38835f065587e128e533d301f8f9debcb09075c44e3e3c0ef", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "normative", "readiness": "breakthrough-dependent", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Current in-space printing is one bounded process. NASA manufacturing standards and portfolios show that feedstock, machines, joining, post-processing, inspection, acceptance, recycling, maintenance, and configuration are coupled capabilities. Requiring the factory to renew itself is a systems inference from permanent loss of external supply." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Portfolio architecture and sections on polymer, metal, electronics, welding, recycling, biomanufacturing, and cross-cutting verification.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "locator": "Sections 4 through 7 on part classification, material and process controls, equipment qualification, witness material, inspection, and acceptance.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "locator": "Reliability and maintainability objectives across design, verification, operations, restoration, and lifecycle support.", "relation": "direct-method" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "An independently replicated end-to-end factory that maintains its own process equipment and metrology while repeatedly producing qualified replacements from declared local inputs would raise readiness; a validated architecture that avoids local industrial renewal would narrow the requirement.", "highConsequence": [] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-02", "title": "Polymer printing, sample metal printing, welding experiments, robotic servicing, and limited recycling have flown.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-02", "recordFingerprint": "56fc4c928628bba3c151043e7d4b98b7c489d4243b773383f7e050539b2abd46", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "dual-use", "materials-assurance", "spacecraft-safety", "supply-chain" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "dual-use-risk" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "dual-use-risk", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-02", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 0 }, "statement": "Polymer printing, sample metal printing, welding experiments, robotic servicing, and limited recycling have flown.", "statementFingerprint": "cd1698fead7b68c8c50c3610206992317cedc9085bc5991e05a4938b4e665239", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "operational", "confidence": "strong", "rationale": "NASA and GAO records document flight or orbital demonstrations of polymer additive manufacturing, sample metal printing, welding or joining experiments, robotic servicing, and limited plastics recycling. Operational applies to these bounded demonstrations and outputs, not to autonomous production of qualified critical parts or a closed industrial ecosystem." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "locator": "Capability status sections covering in-situ fabrication and repair, polymer and metal manufacturing, joining, inspection, robotic servicing, assembly, construction, and flight demonstrations.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Portfolio sections on polymer manufacturing and Refabricator, metal manufacturing, welding and joining, recycling, electronics, biomanufacturing, verification, and demonstration status.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "locator": "Pages 8–24 on demonstrated servicing and assembly, lower manufacturing maturity, test opportunities, standards gaps, and adoption barriers.", "relation": "context-only" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Autonomous Habitat Assurance could benefit from presenting flight demonstrations as inputs to a larger spares and qualification roadmap; no NASA, GAO, manufacturer, servicer, customer, or supplier relationship is claimed." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Retraction or contrary program records would narrow the demonstrated list. Repeated production and repair of representative critical parts with controlled feedstock, metrology, inspection, acceptance, installation, service history, recycling, and independent reproduction would raise integrated readiness; a printed sample alone would not.", "highConsequence": [ "materials-assurance", "supply-chain", "spacecraft-safety", "dual-use" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-03", "title": "Ground programs are advancing regolith excavation, oxygen/metals extraction, large structures, and autonomous manufacturing cells.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-03", "recordFingerprint": "c6de3da170313a1e2e0b2c89db9ae59b595887c03ec9d26e4714989cdf33c832", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-moxie-science", "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "src-im-nasa-isru-priorities" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-03", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Ground programs are advancing regolith excavation, oxygen/metals extraction, large structures, and autonomous manufacturing cells.", "statementFingerprint": "1bf7fdb26b78605fa7a0f3013ad5204142fd77c2ff1e5d3c72339b31b113406d", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "strong", "rationale": "NASA program records document active ground work in excavation, resource characterization, oxygen and metal extraction, manufacturing feedstock, robotics, and integrated pilot planning. MOXIE advanced one oxygen-production process to an off-Earth instrument demonstration, while the broader chain remains unintegrated." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isru-priorities", "locator": "Priority list covering lunar water and oxygen mining, metal extraction, manufacturing feedstock, resource assessment, integration, and pilot plants.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "locator": "Functional chain from prospecting and excavation through beneficiation, extraction, product handling, delivery, coordination, and maintenance.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Sections on metals, large structures, joining, recycling, electronics, and autonomous or supervised in-space manufacturing maturation.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-moxie-science", "locator": "Instrument architecture and Mars operating results for solid-oxide electrolysis of atmospheric carbon dioxide.", "relation": "scope-boundary" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Completed integrated ground pilots, off-Earth excavation and processing demonstrations, published negative results, or cancellation and loss of the cited programs would change the maturity and breadth assessment; none alone would establish generation-scale closure.", "highConsequence": [] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-04", "title": "No end-to-end chain was identified in the reviewed public sources that converts mixed waste or ore into an autonomously installed critical part independently accepted against declared requirements.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-04", "recordFingerprint": "dab0d99f8643dd9ec84e855e088691e529a0453089c891572f462388312de61e", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-04", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "current state", "statementRef": { "field": "currentState", "index": 2 }, "statement": "No end-to-end chain was identified in the reviewed public sources that converts mixed waste or ore into an autonomously installed critical part independently accepted against declared requirements.", "statementFingerprint": "97f7c36224461a04fd87feb7b32fd5b47571ab6f48d40288fbc586af8470968b", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "observed", "readiness": "breakthrough-dependent", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "The current NASA and GAO surveys describe component and subsystem demonstrations, development portfolios, limited robotic servicing, and qualification gaps. Within this bounded authoritative corpus, no identified system performs the complete autonomous path from mixed waste or ore to an installed critical part independently accepted against declared requirements. The survey result does not prove that no staged technical path exists." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "locator": "Capability definitions and status survey for in-situ fabrication and repair, manufacturing, inspection, servicing, assembly, and construction.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Separate polymer, metal, electronics, welding, recycling, biomanufacturing, and verification development paths, including incomplete demonstrations.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "locator": "Pages 8 through 24 on demonstrated servicing, lower manufacturing maturity, limited test opportunities, standards gaps, and adoption barriers.", "relation": "direct-observation" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A documented demonstration beginning with heterogeneous waste or native material and ending with autonomous installation and independent acceptance of a safety-relevant part—while accounting for energy, consumables, waste, faults, and maintenance—would directly change this claim.", "highConsequence": [] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-05", "title": "Semiconductors, bearings, seals, lubricants, catalysts, precision optics, tools, and calibration standards remain vitamin inputs.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-05", "recordFingerprint": "87804b0b31aeb165ce994536166bf4c43e0636bea2e0a69b680b3811891ac1df", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "src-im-nasa-eee-873910", "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-05", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 0 }, "statement": "Semiconductors, bearings, seals, lubricants, catalysts, precision optics, tools, and calibration standards remain vitamin inputs.", "statementFingerprint": "6bba131b699f30175a7260a5fc36178a9587ad05a6bef95c972dd429f27a6940", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "observed", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "The semiconductor and assurance sources directly establish specialized materials, equipment, metrology, suppliers, qualification, storage, and radiation-data dependencies. NASA manufacturing sources support analogous tooling, material, inspection, and process dependencies. The listed vitamin inputs are representative rather than exhaustive." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "locator": "Executive summary and lithography-tool example describing thousands of specialized suppliers, materials, equipment, and tiered dependencies.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "locator": "Metrology focus areas spanning material purity and provenance, fabrication, packaging, models, automation, security, and interoperability.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-eee-873910", "locator": "Electronic-part selection, procurement, traceability, test, packaging, storage, application, and assurance requirements.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "locator": "Database purpose and explicit warning that absence of test data is not evidence of radiation tolerance or immunity.", "relation": "limitation" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A product-by-product closure analysis and repeated demonstrations that locally reproduce, substitute, or safely eliminate the listed precision materials, parts, tools, references, and assurance data would narrow or remove individual vitamin-input designations.", "highConsequence": [] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-06", "title": "Recycled feedstock can hide contamination and property drift without extensive metrology and nondestructive evaluation.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-06", "recordFingerprint": "2849ee770fac581137ecdc6c7ebdcab6fad53b781a7f4265c34f63f7c224b117", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "materials-assurance", "spacecraft-safety" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "src-im-nist-ir8036" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-06", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Recycled feedstock can hide contamination and property drift without extensive metrology and nondestructive evaluation.", "statementFingerprint": "35f401a08897c22d1697483f555d43b07dc1ed01afbd135edd4ca8d7b167d0c3", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "demonstrated", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "strong", "rationale": "Current aerospace manufacturing requirements and NIST research treat feedstock genealogy, reuse history, composition, morphology, process variation, calibration, defects, and final properties as qualification variables. The evidence supports contamination and drift as real risks; it does not establish onboard multigenerational assurance." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "locator": "Feedstock-control, reuse, contamination, process qualification, witness-material, inspection, acceptance, and configuration requirements.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "locator": "Program areas for virgin and recycled feedstock characterization, machine and process qualification, in-process sensing, part inspection, and reference data.", "relation": "direct-demonstration" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-ir8036", "locator": "Sections on process variability, defects, inadequate measurement, and the need to connect process parameters and signatures to final part quality.", "relation": "direct-method" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A long-duration closed-loop feedstock program that controls deliberately introduced contaminants and reuse cycles, preserves specified properties, detects drift with independently traceable measurements, and maintains acceptance yield would change readiness and required inspection.", "highConsequence": [ "materials-assurance", "spacecraft-safety" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-07", "title": "Century-scale process equipment must itself be repaired using locally available processes and knowledge.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-07", "recordFingerprint": "cd83bfd96af45aa013fee6fe81ba1c65fe533cef76ebb161a2e004156d43767c", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "src-im-nasa-rm-8729" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-07", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "unknown", "statementRef": { "field": "unknowns", "index": 2 }, "statement": "Century-scale process equipment must itself be repaired using locally available processes and knowledge.", "statementFingerprint": "dc19f591d046b5eba5ad33bbb45cd102c10479b9ac19308e98696492341d4929", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "normative", "readiness": "breakthrough-dependent", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "Current maintainability practice requires access, fault isolation, restoration, test equipment, documentation, skills, and logistics. Permanent loss of an external supply chain extends those requirements to the process equipment, software, metrology, and knowledge that sustain production; the cited portfolio does not demonstrate that recursion." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "locator": "Lifecycle reliability and maintainability objectives, restoration considerations, maintainability verification, and operational data feedback.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "locator": "Design access, testability, fault isolation, handling, standardization, training, demonstration, and sustaining aging systems.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Manufacturing, recycling, joining, inspection, and equipment-development portfolios and recorded demonstration limitations.", "relation": "limitation" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A factory-reproduction matrix plus repeated demonstrations that repair machine tools, furnaces, joining systems, controls, process sensors, and metrology from declared local processes across expert turnover would raise readiness; irreproducible equipment would define a finite mission bound.", "highConsequence": [] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-08", "title": "Autonomous spares planning, repair cells, material passports, and recycled-feedstock assurance benefit remote industry.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-08", "recordFingerprint": "6741478446ad3817e5aee74fef947c2d0812db5c0e49068619b304d704784102", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "cybersecurity", "dual-use", "materials-assurance", "spacecraft-safety", "supply-chain" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "defensive-cyber-safety", "dual-use-risk" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "defensive-cyber-safety", "dual-use-risk", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-08", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "earth benefit", "statementRef": { "field": "earthBenefits", "index": 0 }, "statement": "Autonomous spares planning, repair cells, material passports, and recycled-feedstock assurance benefit remote industry.", "statementFingerprint": "6260fe875239a649ed55c3bb2eed3de6370ad8a0d2e42fdb91a81f40e7981e9f", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "proposed", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "tentative", "rationale": "Maintainability, additive-manufacturing measurement, feedstock control, repairability, and product-passport practices offer relevant methods for remote operations. The bundled claim that autonomous spares planning, repair cells, passports, and recycled-feedstock assurance improve remote-industry outcomes remains context dependent and is not directly demonstrated by one integrated program." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "locator": "Sections on access, testability, fault isolation, standardization, handling, repair tasks, documentation, training, demonstration, and support of aging systems.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "locator": "Sections 4–7 on part classification, feedstock genealogy and reuse, equipment and process qualification, witness material, inspection, acceptance, and configuration.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "locator": "Virgin and recycled feedstock characterization, machine and process qualification, in-process sensing, part inspection, reference materials, and data.", "relation": "direct-method" }, { "sourceId": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "locator": "Durability, reparability, recycled content, remanufacturing, recycling, circularity, information requirements, and Digital Product Passport provisions.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Autonomous spares planning, maintenance evidence, and material passports are explicit parts of the founder product thesis, creating a direct commercial incentive to find remote-industry value; no standard, regulator, manufacturer, or customer endorses the product." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Controlled remote-industry trials must show fewer stockouts, shorter safe restoration, lower lifecycle cost and waste, valid passport lineage, qualified recycled parts, resilient offline operation, and no unacceptable cyber or common-mode planning failure. Forged lineage, unsafe substitutions, model-driven overstock, or inspection gaps would weaken the bundle.", "highConsequence": [ "materials-assurance", "supply-chain", "cybersecurity", "spacecraft-safety", "dual-use" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-09", "title": "Design-for-disassembly and circular qualification reduce waste and supply-chain dependence.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-09", "recordFingerprint": "f8060bbe57c1885ab2e9ffe595a187a5673e4b9e3b56d9f31e2b69f2e30e0ef3", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "dual-use", "materials-assurance", "spacecraft-safety", "supply-chain" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "dual-use-risk" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "dual-use-risk", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "src-ca-epa-sustainable-materials", "src-im-nasa-std-6030" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-09", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "earth benefit", "statementRef": { "field": "earthBenefits", "index": 1 }, "statement": "Design-for-disassembly and circular qualification reduce waste and supply-chain dependence.", "statementFingerprint": "992a9ff9d4cb2a3ab35f7f8222be87d200bbc4b06f79cbf98fe417b497aff9d6", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "proposed", "readiness": "major-scale-up", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "EPA lifecycle guidance and the EU ecodesign framework explicitly connect durability, repairability, disassembly, reuse, remanufacturing, recycling, product information, waste prevention, and lower material-supply risk. Aerospace qualification adds stricter feedstock, process, inspection, and acceptance constraints, so circularity is not equivalent to unrestricted reuse." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-ca-epa-sustainable-materials", "locator": "Lifecycle perspective and design discussion covering material reduction, durability, maintenance, reuse, ready disassembly, recycling, waste prevention, cost, and supply risk.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "locator": "Regulatory summary of durability, upgradability, reparability, recycled content, remanufacturing, recycling, circularity, and Digital Product Passport requirements.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "locator": "Sections 4–7 on feedstock controls, reuse history, contamination, equipment and process qualification, witness material, inspection, acceptance, and nonconformance.", "relation": "scope-boundary" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "The founder thesis benefits from design-for-disassembly and circular qualification as both Earth-first outcomes and future product requirements; no regulator, recycler, manufacturer, material supplier, or standards body relationship is claimed." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "Product-level lifecycle data must show lower virgin input, waste, downtime, environmental burden, and supply disruption while maintaining safety and performance through disassembly and reuse cycles. Rebound consumption, toxic contamination, downcycling, lost provenance, excess qualification burden, or reduced reliability would narrow the claim.", "highConsequence": [ "materials-assurance", "supply-chain", "spacecraft-safety", "dual-use" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim", "recordId": "claim-14-10", "title": "Operate an integrated factory cell through tool wear, sensor drift, contaminated feedstock, missing specialists, and injected cyber faults.", "publicPath": "/claims/claim-14-10", "recordFingerprint": "07bbde2a763e1fbdc38d3a6e80c8e08d6787224579e7b2447ffa8e049517c279", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 2, "highConsequenceDomains": [ "cybersecurity", "life-support-continuity", "spacecraft-safety" ], "requiredDomainCodes": [ "defensive-cyber-safety" ], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "domain-method", "scopeClass": "domain-method", "oneOf": [ "defensive-cyber-safety", "manufacturing-maintenance", "systems-engineering" ] }, { "id": "rights-public-interest", "scopeClass": "rights-public-interest", "oneOf": [ "affected-public-rights" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [ "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "src-im-nist-ot-80082r3", "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1" ], "snapshot": { "id": "claim-14-10", "systemSlug": "manufacturing-isru", "kind": "decision gate", "statementRef": { "field": "gate" }, "statement": "Operate an integrated factory cell through tool wear, sensor drift, contaminated feedstock, missing specialists, and injected cyber faults.", "statementFingerprint": "a895de693efe6c60b07a39c4e2ba216b84d00c583381708bd7f26844cbeb5ac2", "assessment": { "status": "editorial-assessed", "basis": "normative", "readiness": "early-research", "confidence": "supported", "rationale": "The test gate combines observed manufacturing failure modes, existing qualification controls, lifecycle maintainability, OT cybersecurity, and the documented incompleteness of current in-space manufacturing. It is a proposed acceptance test rather than evidence that any factory has passed." }, "citations": [ { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "locator": "Refabricator filament-breakage and foreign-object-debris outcome plus portfolio needs for recycling, process control, inspection, and manufacturing maturation.", "relation": "direct-observation" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "locator": "Feedstock, equipment, process, configuration, witness-material, inspection, acceptance, and nonconformance requirements.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "locator": "Reliability and maintainability planning, test, demonstration, operations, and improvement objectives.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-ot-80082r3", "locator": "OT threat, integrity, segmentation, maintenance, incident response, and recovery guidance under safety and availability constraints.", "relation": "direct-normative-authority" }, { "sourceId": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "locator": "Sections on confabulation, information integrity, component integration, value-chain risk, evaluation, and consequential human oversight.", "relation": "scope-boundary" } ], "contextSourceIds": [ "core-14-1", "core-14-2", "core-14-3" ], "editorialProvenance": { "status": "substantive-editorial-review", "reviewers": [ "GShips Project editorial synthesis" ], "conflicts": [ "Publisher intends to explore a commercial venture based on some GShips work." ] }, "whatWouldChange": "A completed, independently observed factory-cell campaign that survives all five fault classes, produces independently qualified outputs, restores known-good control, publishes failures, and repeats after staff turnover would satisfy this bounded gate; a stronger reviewed protocol could replace it.", "highConsequence": [ "cybersecurity", "spacecraft-safety", "life-support-continuity" ] } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "title": "Sustainable Products to Become the Norm as the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation Enters into Force", "publicPath": "https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/sustainable-products-be-norm-consumers-new-regulation-2024-07-19_en", "recordFingerprint": "da81477d420591afc612b54ac8d62736160ef75e96843cf9c74c3d680218059e", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "title": "Sustainable Products to Become the Norm as the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation Enters into Force", "authors": [ "European Commission Directorate-General for Environment" ], "publisher": "European Commission", "year": 2024, "url": "https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/sustainable-products-be-norm-consumers-new-regulation-2024-07-19_en", "kind": "official-regulatory-summary", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Durability, reparability, recycled content, remanufacturing, recycling, circularity, environmental information, and Digital Product Passport provisions, with implementation still progressing by product group." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "title": "JPL Radiation Effects Database", "publicPath": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/go/space-radiation/radiation-database/", "recordFingerprint": "034ab1d0da86af17631b632d49c139753286d3d07ff7c633c1fa7005457d206b", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "title": "JPL Radiation Effects Database", "authors": [ "Jet Propulsion Laboratory Center for Space Radiation" ], "publisher": "NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/go/space-radiation/radiation-database/", "kind": "institutional-test-data-resource", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Radiation-effects test data and assurance context, including the warning that absent data is not evidence of tolerance or immunity. The official page is browser-accessible but returns HTTP 403 to automated checks." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-moxie-science", "title": "Mars Oxygen ISRU Experiment (MOXIE)—Preparing for Human Mars Exploration", "publicPath": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abp8636", "recordFingerprint": "936cbbaae07311b3b8cd4aff7c8b0c48720498eb4753a55f50009ba1670b6e47", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-moxie-science", "title": "Mars Oxygen ISRU Experiment (MOXIE)—Preparing for Human Mars Exploration", "authors": [ "Jeffrey A. Hoffman", "Michael H. Hecht", "Donald Rapp", "MOXIE Team" ], "publisher": "Science Advances", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abp8636", "kind": "peer-reviewed-off-earth-demonstration", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Primary results and scale boundary for oxygen production from Martian atmospheric carbon dioxide. The stable DOI resolves in browser access but the publisher returns HTTP 403 to automated checks." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "title": "Autonomy and Robotics Needed for Integrated ISRU Operations", "publicPath": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20240013907", "recordFingerprint": "98d607701b4c6a9cfffd9f565a8baf370844c371eddbf9769a9454c5cf53a303", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "title": "Autonomy and Robotics Needed for Integrated ISRU Operations", "authors": [ "Gerald B. Sanders" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 2024, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20240013907", "kind": "institutional-technical-presentation", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Robotic and autonomous functions across prospecting, excavation, transport, beneficiation, extraction, product handling, coordination, and maintenance." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "title": "Measurement Science for Additive Manufacturing Program", "publicPath": "https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/measurement-science-additive-manufacturing-program", "recordFingerprint": "c8f6eb76b1a5e91f56d4320b96e92ada9823a967a01df2bc463a43da497d8fdd", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "title": "Measurement Science for Additive Manufacturing Program", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/measurement-science-additive-manufacturing-program", "kind": "institutional-research-program", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Material characterization, process sensing and control, machine and feedstock qualification, part inspection, data, reference methods, and model validation." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "title": "Metrology Gaps in the Semiconductor Ecosystem", "publicPath": "https://www.nist.gov/document/chips-rd-metrology-gaps-semiconductor-ecosystem", "recordFingerprint": "262322d91a33825ba17c2527a26293c60e798749a6b8a45652effb3e5bc333fd", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "title": "Metrology Gaps in the Semiconductor Ecosystem", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/document/chips-rd-metrology-gaps-semiconductor-ecosystem", "kind": "government-semiconductor-metrology-roadmap", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Metrology needs across materials, devices, fabrication, advanced packaging, models, automation, security, provenance, interoperability, and standards." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "title": "Vision for Success: Facilities for Semiconductor Materials and Manufacturing Equipment", "publicPath": "https://www.nist.gov/chips/vision-success-facilities-semiconductor-materials-and-manufacturing-equipment", "recordFingerprint": "346c53795aeb4a6e01fb5ada14ae8125e3e4a008c537bbb6a3103bd70d10cae3", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "title": "Vision for Success: Facilities for Semiconductor Materials and Manufacturing Equipment", "authors": [ "NIST CHIPS Program Office" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/chips/vision-success-facilities-semiconductor-materials-and-manufacturing-equipment", "kind": "government-semiconductor-supply-chain-assessment", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Global specialization, thousands of suppliers, geographic concentration, materials, equipment, and multi-tier dependencies in semiconductor manufacturing." } }, { "recordType": "claim-source", "recordId": "src-im-nist-ir8036", "title": "Measurement Science Needs for Real-time Control of Additive Manufacturing Powder Bed Fusion Processes", "publicPath": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.IR.8036", "recordFingerprint": "aa3f92c0e41852f17a4d8ae0c3c7d278dea7eda098a9bc69b9a8ee8ebc87ce5b", "reviewRequirements": { "minimumIndependentApprovals": 1, "highConsequenceDomains": [], "requiredDomainCodes": [], "requiredComplementaryScopeGroups": [ { "id": "bounded-competence", "scopeClass": "bounded-competence", "oneOf": [ "information-science" ] } ], "unresolvedNegativeFindingBlocksPublication": true }, "referenceIds": [], "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-ir8036", "title": "Measurement Science Needs for Real-time Control of Additive Manufacturing Powder Bed Fusion Processes", "authors": [ "Mahesh Mani", "Brandon Lane", "Alkan Donmez", "Shawn C. Feng", "Shawn P. Moylan", "Ronnie R. Fesperman Jr." ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.IR.8036", "kind": "government-technical-report", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Traceable dimensional and thermal metrology gaps and relationships among powder-bed-fusion process parameters, process signatures, and part quality." } } ], "linkedRecords": [], "referenceSnapshots": [ { "sourceId": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "da81477d420591afc612b54ac8d62736160ef75e96843cf9c74c3d680218059e", "snapshot": { "id": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "title": "Sustainable Products to Become the Norm as the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation Enters into Force", "authors": [ "European Commission Directorate-General for Environment" ], "publisher": "European Commission", "year": 2024, "url": "https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/sustainable-products-be-norm-consumers-new-regulation-2024-07-19_en", "kind": "official-regulatory-summary", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Durability, reparability, recycled content, remanufacturing, recycling, circularity, environmental information, and Digital Product Passport provisions, with implementation still progressing by product group." } }, { "sourceId": "src-ca-epa-sustainable-materials", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "49e6a2bd9da17780e064bb9bb0803718f2d216c68f7e812b97224a9da99aa7c5", "snapshot": { "id": "src-ca-epa-sustainable-materials", "title": "Sustainable Materials Management Basics", "authors": [ "U.S. Environmental Protection Agency" ], "publisher": "U.S. Environmental Protection Agency", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.epa.gov/smm/sustainable-materials-management-basics", "kind": "government-materials-lifecycle-guidance", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Lifecycle framing for material extraction, manufacture, use, reuse, maintenance, and waste management across food, buildings, products, and circular-economy contexts." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "f34a4c41466659821eede3dfde4b257733374fd7d50c558c8f7d1bbb1078a8e7", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-gao-isam-2025", "title": "In-Space Servicing, Assembly, and Manufacturing: Benefits, Challenges, and Policy Options", "authors": [ "U.S. Government Accountability Office" ], "publisher": "U.S. Government Accountability Office", "year": 2025, "url": "https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-25-107555", "kind": "government-technology-assessment", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Independent government assessment of demonstrated servicing, limited robotic use, test-access gaps, emerging standards, serviceability, costs, and policy options." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "034ab1d0da86af17631b632d49c139753286d3d07ff7c633c1fa7005457d206b", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "title": "JPL Radiation Effects Database", "authors": [ "Jet Propulsion Laboratory Center for Space Radiation" ], "publisher": "NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/go/space-radiation/radiation-database/", "kind": "institutional-test-data-resource", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Radiation-effects test data and assurance context, including the warning that absent data is not evidence of tolerance or immunity. The official page is browser-accessible but returns HTTP 403 to automated checks." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-moxie-science", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "936cbbaae07311b3b8cd4aff7c8b0c48720498eb4753a55f50009ba1670b6e47", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-moxie-science", "title": "Mars Oxygen ISRU Experiment (MOXIE)—Preparing for Human Mars Exploration", "authors": [ "Jeffrey A. Hoffman", "Michael H. Hecht", "Donald Rapp", "MOXIE Team" ], "publisher": "Science Advances", "year": 2022, "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abp8636", "kind": "peer-reviewed-off-earth-demonstration", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Primary results and scale boundary for oxygen production from Martian atmospheric carbon dioxide. The stable DOI resolves in browser access but the publisher returns HTTP 403 to automated checks." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-eee-873910", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "7de974366c68ddd53ce47a7829040b0f7d644de2713f873827f7eacbe97c2287", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-eee-873910", "title": "Electrical, Electronic, and Electromechanical Parts Assurance Standard", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2017, "url": "https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/NASA/NASA-STD-873910", "kind": "active-electronic-parts-assurance-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Selection, acquisition, traceability, testing, handling, packaging, storage, application, and risk control for spaceflight electronic and electromechanical parts." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "4ee5cffad11832f3a52484c44217ef44f63bb5d5da9e3d47186f35fea1ab886d", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-isam-2025", "title": "In-Space Servicing, Assembly, and Manufacturing State of Play: 2025 Edition", "authors": [ "John Mulvaney", "Dale Arney", "Christina Williams", "Jose Morel", "Christopher Stockdale", "Christopher Whitlock", "Vishruth Balaji" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 2025, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250008988", "kind": "institutional-state-of-the-art", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "NASA peer-committee-reviewed taxonomy and status survey of inspection, servicing, assembly, fabrication, repair, construction, and enabling capabilities." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "06cea319893cf8240cb44a60e3ce511ca3f41a48b46c87b9915567ef6fc29ba1", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-ism-portfolio-2025", "title": "In-Space Manufacturing Portfolio Plan", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 2025, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250004020", "kind": "institutional-technology-portfolio", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Program record for polymer, metal, electronics, welding, recycling, inspection, and biomanufacturing work, including the incomplete ISS Refabricator demonstration." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "98d607701b4c6a9cfffd9f565a8baf370844c371eddbf9769a9454c5cf53a303", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "title": "Autonomy and Robotics Needed for Integrated ISRU Operations", "authors": [ "Gerald B. Sanders" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 2024, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20240013907", "kind": "institutional-technical-presentation", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Robotic and autonomous functions across prospecting, excavation, transport, beneficiation, extraction, product handling, coordination, and maintenance." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-isru-priorities", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "751943e37363db62202ca505da89bdf66ce92100ad7f54d63af0c5e0618cb6fb", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-isru-priorities", "title": "Overview of NASA ISRU Plans, Priorities, and Activities", "authors": [ "Gerald B. Sanders", "Julie E. Kleinhenz" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 2022, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20220007350", "kind": "institutional-technology-roadmap", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "NASA priorities for water and oxygen mining, metal and manufacturing feedstock, resource assessment, integration, and end-to-end pilot demonstrations." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "8d07e8e57c8b39afc5ed42418438ee95064f7602aeb1849436bec43bac7d270c", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-maintainability-tm4628", "title": "Recommended Techniques for Effective Maintainability", "authors": [ "NASA Reliability and Maintainability Steering Committee" ], "publisher": "NASA Technical Reports Server", "year": 1994, "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19950025109", "kind": "institutional-maintainability-handbook", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Design access, fault isolation, testability, standardization, handling, maintenance analysis, demonstration, training, and operational restoration." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "1adc452418fbda7d9b7258bee174773a26d9b60c7ee5859ac78c77443cf1866d", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-rm-8729", "title": "NASA Reliability and Maintainability Standard for Spaceflight and Support Systems", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2017, "url": "https://standards.nasa.gov/node/279", "kind": "active-reliability-maintainability-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Lifecycle reliability and maintainability objectives, planning, analysis, verification, validation, and evidence for NASA programs." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "7e6a5d45f27e760d46772f9f030ecd9397047f8274aa4525946c18e6d6b34d90", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nasa-std-6030", "title": "Additive Manufacturing Requirements for Spaceflight Systems", "authors": [ "National Aeronautics and Space Administration" ], "publisher": "NASA", "year": 2021, "url": "https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/NASA/NASA-STD-6030", "kind": "active-spaceflight-manufacturing-standard", "checkedAt": "2026-07-26", "version": "Baseline", "changeNumber": 0, "documentDate": "2021-04-21", "status": "ACTIVE", "reviewDue": "2026-04-21", "freshnessNote": "NASA still marks the baseline ACTIVE even though the listed five-year review date has passed; GShips therefore treats it as current-with-review-due rather than obsolete.", "scopeNote": "Requirements for part classification, feedstock and process control, machine qualification, witness material, inspection, acceptance, configuration, and tailored in-space additive manufacturing. This is normative authority for NASA spaceflight hardware, not a demonstration of printed-part performance, autonomous repair, circular manufacturing, or cyber recovery." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "c8f6eb76b1a5e91f56d4320b96e92ada9823a967a01df2bc463a43da497d8fdd", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "title": "Measurement Science for Additive Manufacturing Program", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2026, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/measurement-science-additive-manufacturing-program", "kind": "institutional-research-program", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Material characterization, process sensing and control, machine and feedstock qualification, part inspection, data, reference methods, and model validation." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "262322d91a33825ba17c2527a26293c60e798749a6b8a45652effb3e5bc333fd", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "title": "Metrology Gaps in the Semiconductor Ecosystem", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/document/chips-rd-metrology-gaps-semiconductor-ecosystem", "kind": "government-semiconductor-metrology-roadmap", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Metrology needs across materials, devices, fabrication, advanced packaging, models, automation, security, provenance, interoperability, and standards." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "346c53795aeb4a6e01fb5ada14ae8125e3e4a008c537bbb6a3103bd70d10cae3", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "title": "Vision for Success: Facilities for Semiconductor Materials and Manufacturing Equipment", "authors": [ "NIST CHIPS Program Office" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2023, "url": "https://www.nist.gov/chips/vision-success-facilities-semiconductor-materials-and-manufacturing-equipment", "kind": "government-semiconductor-supply-chain-assessment", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Global specialization, thousands of suppliers, geographic concentration, materials, equipment, and multi-tier dependencies in semiconductor manufacturing." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-ir8036", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "aa3f92c0e41852f17a4d8ae0c3c7d278dea7eda098a9bc69b9a8ee8ebc87ce5b", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-ir8036", "title": "Measurement Science Needs for Real-time Control of Additive Manufacturing Powder Bed Fusion Processes", "authors": [ "Mahesh Mani", "Brandon Lane", "Alkan Donmez", "Shawn C. Feng", "Shawn P. Moylan", "Ronnie R. Fesperman Jr." ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2015, "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.IR.8036", "kind": "government-technical-report", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Traceable dimensional and thermal metrology gaps and relationships among powder-bed-fusion process parameters, process signatures, and part quality." } }, { "sourceId": "src-im-nist-ot-80082r3", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "079024b69f4ab4aeaa8755b5bf62674b9f4cae4428d4ea97744c9cb78cdb593e", "snapshot": { "id": "src-im-nist-ot-80082r3", "title": "Guide to Operational Technology Security", "authors": [ "Keith Stouffer", "Michael Pease", "CheeYee Tang", "Timothy Zimmerman", "Victoria Pillitteri", "Suzanne Lightman", "Adam Hahn", "Stephanie Saravia", "Aslam Sherule", "Michael Thompson" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2023, "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.SP.800-82r3", "kind": "government-cybersecurity-guidance", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Operational-technology architectures, safety and availability constraints, threats, segmentation, supply-chain and maintenance risks, countermeasures, and recovery." } }, { "sourceId": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "sourceRecordType": "claim-source", "sourceFingerprint": "4066eeecafdc810d0ad828dd8bd53e4a05daeb6b03dde36fafe581976402cb59", "snapshot": { "id": "src-pa-nist-ai-600-1", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile", "authors": [ "National Institute of Standards and Technology" ], "publisher": "NIST", "year": 2024, "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1", "kind": "government-risk-management-profile", "checkedAt": "2026-07-25", "scopeNote": "Generative-AI governance, provenance, evaluation, security, confabulation, privacy, and incident disclosure." } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "694c69845f2589cad31e23ef9771c5c2ecabdc0eef04bd32d63d818c97180a7b", "snapshot": { "title": "Sustainable Products to Become the Norm as the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation Enters into Force", "url": "https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/sustainable-products-be-norm-consumers-new-regulation-2024-07-19_en", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-c814-eu-ecodesign-regulation" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-jpl-radiation-database", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "d12dd5c8aaed6c854178dc7baf991f9ec95a1ac5f5868ed8d413e27d3bddf028", "snapshot": { "title": "JPL Radiation Effects Database", "url": "https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/go/space-radiation/radiation-database/", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-jpl-radiation-database" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-moxie-science", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "1ecc4c6df0032fd70fe7926c66db2d609471a3e5bdeff9abc02ab92fba42f54e", "snapshot": { "title": "Mars Oxygen ISRU Experiment (MOXIE)—Preparing for Human Mars Exploration", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abp8636", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-moxie-science" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "bbd0238d13dff46d142b2e5a846c4b14edd5c743cc37437bceb628c0a86f408c", "snapshot": { "title": "Autonomy and Robotics Needed for Integrated ISRU Operations", "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20240013907", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-nasa-isru-autonomy" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-nist-am-measurement-program", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "4325c574a5f7baa5c3f844591ee04bb1f7a6eb4eaf97b018fe51aeafbd270332", "snapshot": { "title": "Measurement Science for Additive Manufacturing Program", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/programs-projects/measurement-science-additive-manufacturing-program", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-nist-am-measurement-program" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-nist-chips-metrology", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "007c0cd3dea1c88c4a5b5def9ab6de0a8530183ffa21598d2ed6afa77ffe6ee8", "snapshot": { "title": "Metrology Gaps in the Semiconductor Ecosystem", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/document/chips-rd-metrology-gaps-semiconductor-ecosystem", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-nist-chips-metrology" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "e426ea8416ef313424a980d6cd4d9240bc31f1d51264bf6f41a3e66d57b65801", "snapshot": { "title": "Vision for Success: Facilities for Semiconductor Materials and Manufacturing Equipment", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/chips/vision-success-facilities-semiconductor-materials-and-manufacturing-equipment", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-nist-chips-supply-chain" } }, { "sourceId": "official-claim-source-src-im-nist-ir8036", "sourceRecordType": "reference-source", "sourceFingerprint": "5eb842efcdff98a08230bc913eab663025ee93d91d419ed8696fc4746dd96274", "snapshot": { "title": "Measurement Science Needs for Real-time Control of Additive Manufacturing Powder Bed Fusion Processes", "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.IR.8036", "checkedAt": null, "scopeNote": "Official subject link frozen with the reviewed record; it does not independently validate every profile conclusion.", "subjectRecordType": "claim-source", "subjectRecordId": "src-im-nist-ir8036" } } ], "packetFingerprint": "6bd3638d8bcb9c531c2a88c88d61cda6b02aa94ec4267b86b89a06fbc1f1f3d8" }